Uncertainty modeling for fine-tuned implicit functions
Anna Susmelj, Mael Macuglia, Nata\v{s}a Tagasovska, Reto Sutter,, Sebastiano Caprara, Jean-Philippe Thiran, Ender Konukoglu

TL;DR
This paper introduces Dropsembles, a new uncertainty estimation method for fine-tuned implicit functions like NeRFs and SDFs, enhancing reconstruction reliability especially under data sparsity and corruption.
Contribution
Dropsembles provides an efficient uncertainty estimation technique that matches deep ensembles in accuracy and calibration but requires less computational resources.
Findings
Dropsembles achieves comparable accuracy to deep ensembles.
Dropsembles offers better calibration than other methods.
Effective in real-world medical imaging scenarios.
Abstract
Implicit functions such as Neural Radiance Fields (NeRFs), occupancy networks, and signed distance functions (SDFs) have become pivotal in computer vision for reconstructing detailed object shapes from sparse views. Achieving optimal performance with these models can be challenging due to the extreme sparsity of inputs and distribution shifts induced by data corruptions. To this end, large, noise-free synthetic datasets can serve as shape priors to help models fill in gaps, but the resulting reconstructions must be approached with caution. Uncertainty estimation is crucial for assessing the quality of these reconstructions, particularly in identifying areas where the model is uncertain about the parts it has inferred from the prior. In this paper, we introduce Dropsembles, a novel method for uncertainty estimation in tuned implicit functions. We demonstrate the efficacy of our approach…
Peer Reviews
Decision·ICLR 2025 Poster
Key contributions include: (1) A method for modeling epistemic uncertainty in fine-tuned implicit functions. (2) The application of Elastic Weight Consolidation (EWC) to address distribution shifts. (3) Experimental validation across toy and real-world datasets.
(1) **Questionable motivation for EWC**: **Lack of task distinction**: The dense and sparse datasets (Tasks A and B) are similar in content, which doesn’t align well with the typical use case for EWC in continual learning. EWC is usually applied to preserve knowledge across distinct tasks, so its application here appears unjustified or artificial. (2) **Limited novelty in dropsembles**: **Lack of specificity to NIR**: Dropsembles combines dropout with ensembling in a straightforward way witho
- The focus on uncertainty modeling in fine-tuned neural implicit functions addresses an underexplored area, contributing valuable insights into this challenging problem space. - Dropsembles combines dropout and deep ensembles, offering a computationally efficient training method for uncertainty estimation specifically tailored to neural implicit functions. This application of established uncertainty quantification and continual learning techniques to neural implicit functions is considered a
- While the method shows promise in specific tasks like lumbar spine reconstruction, broader application beyond medical imaging is not thoroughly explored or validated. - Despite reduced costs compared to deep ensembles, Dropsembles still require significant resources during fine-tuning, especially on high-resolution data. - Although Dropsembles handle sparse inputs well, the effectiveness on highly varied real-world scenarios with extreme data corruption could have been examined more comprehens
Originality: While the paper builds upon technical concepts from the uncertainty modeling community and does not introduce novel technical components, I believe the explored application and conclusions are novel and impactful. Quality: The paper is very well structured and intuitive. The presentation and writing of the method are very clear, and in combination with the experiments, the method is sound. Clarity: The paper is well written in all sections, especially in related work and methods
1) Related Work: As detailed above, the paper is very well written and conducts a very thorough related work section. However, I think it would be important to touch upon one more area - i.e. the more recent architectures used in cohort-based training that also use encoder frameworks. Specifically, it would be interesting to discuss the advancements in [1,2], given that these constitute more recent alternatives to the DeepSDF architecture. As both works [1,2] use encoder-/decoder settings in co
Videos
Taxonomy
TopicsProbabilistic and Robust Engineering Design
MethodsDeep Ensembles
