Aligning Vision Models with Human Aesthetics in Retrieval: Benchmarks and Algorithms

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel approach to align vision models with human aesthetic standards in retrieval systems by leveraging LLM reasoning, reinforcement learning, and new benchmarks, significantly improving aesthetic alignment.

Contribution

It proposes a preference-based reinforcement learning method that distills knowledge from LLMs and aesthetic models to better align vision models with human aesthetics, along with new benchmarks for evaluation.

Findings

Enhanced aesthetic alignment in vision models demonstrated by improved metrics.

Utilization of LLM reasoning extends aesthetic expectations beyond low-level features.

Introduction of the HPIR dataset for robust evaluation of aesthetic alignment.

Abstract

Modern vision models are trained on very large noisy datasets. While these models acquire strong capabilities, they may not follow the user's intent to output the desired results in certain aspects, e.g., visual aesthetic, preferred style, and responsibility. In this paper, we target the realm of visual aesthetics and aim to align vision models with human aesthetic standards in a retrieval system. Advanced retrieval systems usually adopt a cascade of aesthetic models as re-rankers or filters, which are limited to low-level features like saturation and perform poorly when stylistic, cultural or knowledge contexts are involved. We find that utilizing the reasoning ability of large language models (LLMs) to rephrase the search query and extend the aesthetic expectations can make up for this shortcoming. Based on the above findings, we propose a preference-based reinforcement learning method that fine-tunes the vision models to distill the knowledge from both LLMs reasoning and the aesthetic models to better align the vision models with human aesthetics. Meanwhile, with rare benchmarks designed for evaluating retrieval systems, we leverage large multi-modality model (LMM) to evaluate the aesthetic performance with their strong abilities. As aesthetic assessment is one of the most subjective tasks, to validate the robustness of LMM, we further propose a novel dataset named HPIR to benchmark the alignment with human aesthetics. Experiments demonstrate that our method significantly enhances the aesthetic behaviors of the vision models, under several metrics. We believe the proposed algorithm can be a general practice for aligning vision models with human values.