Scaling Large Language Model-based Multi-Agent Collaboration
Chen Qian, Zihao Xie, YiFei Wang, Wei Liu, Kunlun Zhu, Hanchen Xia,, Yufan Dang, Zhuoyun Du, Weize Chen, Cheng Yang, Zhiyuan Liu, Maosong Sun

TL;DR
This paper introduces MacNet, a multi-agent collaboration network that scales with many agents, demonstrating a collaborative scaling law where performance improves logistically as agents increase, enhancing collective reasoning.
Contribution
It proposes a novel multi-agent collaboration architecture using directed acyclic graphs and uncovers a collaborative scaling law in large language model-based multi-agent systems.
Findings
Supports over a thousand agents in collaboration.
Irregular topologies outperform regular ones.
Performance follows a logistic growth pattern with scaling.
Abstract
Recent breakthroughs in large language model-driven autonomous agents have revealed that multi-agent collaboration often surpasses each individual through collective reasoning. Inspired by the neural scaling law--increasing neurons enhances performance, this study explores whether the continuous addition of collaborative agents can yield similar benefits. Technically, we utilize directed acyclic graphs to organize agents into a multi-agent collaboration network (MacNet), upon which their interactive reasoning is topologically orchestrated for autonomous task solving. Extensive evaluations reveal that it effectively supports collaboration among over a thousand agents, with irregular topologies outperforming regular ones. We also identify a collaborative scaling law--the overall performance follows a logistic growth pattern as agents scale, with collaborative emergence occurring earlier…
Peer Reviews
Decision·ICLR 2025 Poster
- The paper introduces a pioneering framework that employs directed acyclic graphs (DAGs) to organize agents within a multi-agent system. It provides insightful comparisons between various topologies. - The research delves into the impact of scaling the number of collaborative agents on overall performance, uncovering a collaborative scaling law. This law suggests that performance follows a logistic growth pattern as agents are added, which is a significant finding as it parallels the neural sc
Check in Questions.
1. The paper is clearly articulated and well-structured, with the discussion on "why random topologies perform better" and "tail aspects being factors leading to the emergence of collaboration" being particularly enlightening. 2. The experimental section of the paper is comprehensive (although there may be areas lacking in rigor), covering a wide range of perspectives in its design. I believe the work presented in this paper can inspire the entire research community.
As an empirical research paper, the experimental design and conclusions of the paper are particularly important and need to be sufficiently rigorous. I currently have some concerns. (Major) 1. Regarding the emergence in multi-agent systems. The paper discusses the laws of neural scale emergence and agent collaboration emergence between lines 427 and 429. However, the claim of collaboration emergence might not be rigorous enough. For instance, in neural emergence, a neural network model can evol
The scaling of multi-agent systems powered by LLMs is a significant research question for the community. The idea of organizing LLM agents using a DAG is not novel; however, the authors present a comprehensive analysis of factors including types of topologies, densities, directions, and scales. The experiments involve at maximum of 1000 LLM agents, with the help of the proposed memory control mechanism to avoid context explosion. The proposed method is highly flexible and generalizable, requ
What is the rationale for using "instructor" for edges and "executor" for nodes? It seems that both can be treated as nodes with different profiles, with edges between them indicating interactions. Implementation details are somewhat brief. As mentioned in lines 259-261, agent profiles and tools are generated by GPT-4 and randomly assigned to network agents. It is unclear how this process can be fully automated without interventions or adjustments at the scale of 1,000+ agents. Is there any gua
Code & Models
Videos
Taxonomy
TopicsMulti-Agent Systems and Negotiation · Service-Oriented Architecture and Web Services · Semantic Web and Ontologies
