X-ray Afterglow limits on the viewing angles of short gamma-ray bursts

TL;DR

This study uses early X-ray afterglow data from 58 short gamma-ray bursts to constrain their viewing angles and jet structures, revealing most are observed near their jet cores, impacting models of gamma-ray production and detection rates.

Contribution

It provides the first comprehensive constraints on the viewing angles of short gamma-ray bursts using early X-ray afterglow observations, supporting on-axis or near-core viewing scenarios.

Findings

Most sGRBs are viewed within the jet core or very close to it.

Constraints on the initial Lorentz factor suggest extremely high values if viewed off-axis.

Implications for gamma-ray production mechanisms and gravitational wave counterpart detection rates.

Abstract

The observed behavior of a short gamma-ray burst (sGRB) afterglow lightcurve can reveal the angular structure of the relativistic jet and constrain the observer's viewing angle $\theta_\textrm{obs}$. Regardless of viewing angle, the afterglow emission is produced by the interaction between the relativistic jet and its surrounding environment. However, the observed deceleration time of the jet, and, therefore, the time of the afterglow peak, depends on the observer's viewing angle. A larger viewing angle leads to a later peak of the afterglow and a lower flux at peak. We use the the earliest X-ray afterglow detections of 58 cosmological sGRBs detected with the Neil Gehrels Swift Observatory X-ray Telescope to set an upper limit on the ratio of the viewing angle $\theta_\textrm{obs}$ to the jet's half-opening angle $\theta_\textrm{c}$. We adopt a power-law angular jet structure in both energy $E(\theta)\propto\theta^{-a}$ and Lorentz factor $\Gamma(\theta)\propto\theta^{-b}$ beyond the core. For this structured jet scenario we find that either sGRBs are viewed within $\theta_\textrm{obs}/\theta_\textrm{c}<1$ or the initial Lorentz factor of material in their jet's core is extremely high ($\Gamma_0>500$). If we consider a tophat jet structure, we constrain 90% of our sample to be viewed within $\theta_\textrm{obs}/\theta_\textrm{c}<1.06$ and 1.15 for our canonical and conservative afterglow scenarios. For a subset of events with measurements of the jet break, under the assumption that they on-axis we can constrain $\Gamma_0\theta_\textrm{c}\gtrsim 30$. This confirmation that cosmological sGRBs are viewed either on-axis or very close to their jet's core has significant implications for the nature of the prompt gamma-ray production mechanism and for the rate of future sGRB detections coincident with gravitational waves (GWs), implying that they are extremely rare.