Reproducibility Study on Adversarial Attacks Against Robust Transformer Trackers

TL;DR

This study evaluates the robustness of transformer-based object trackers against adversarial attacks, revealing that stronger cross-attention models exhibit greater resilience and highlighting the need for new attack strategies.

Contribution

It provides a comprehensive empirical analysis of adversarial robustness across various transformer and non-transformer trackers on multiple datasets.

Findings

Transformer trackers with stronger cross-attention are more robust.

Alteration of perturbation levels does not significantly impact attack effectiveness.

Current attack methods may be insufficient against advanced transformer trackers.

Abstract

New transformer networks have been integrated into object tracking pipelines and have demonstrated strong performance on the latest benchmarks. This paper focuses on understanding how transformer trackers behave under adversarial attacks and how different attacks perform on tracking datasets as their parameters change. We conducted a series of experiments to evaluate the effectiveness of existing adversarial attacks on object trackers with transformer and non-transformer backbones. We experimented on 7 different trackers, including 3 that are transformer-based, and 4 which leverage other architectures. These trackers are tested against 4 recent attack methods to assess their performance and robustness on VOT2022ST, UAV123 and GOT10k datasets. Our empirical study focuses on evaluating adversarial robustness of object trackers based on bounding box versus binary mask predictions, and attack methods at different levels of perturbations. Interestingly, our study found that altering the perturbation level may not significantly affect the overall object tracking results after the attack. Similarly, the sparsity and imperceptibility of the attack perturbations may remain stable against perturbation level shifts. By applying a specific attack on all transformer trackers, we show that new transformer trackers having a stronger cross-attention modeling achieve a greater adversarial robustness on tracking datasets, such as VOT2022ST and GOT10k. Our results also indicate the necessity for new attack methods to effectively tackle the latest types of transformer trackers. The codes necessary to reproduce this study are available at https://github.com/fatemehN/ReproducibilityStudy.