GATE: How to Keep Out Intrusive Neighbors
Nimrah Mustafa, Rebekka Burkholz

TL;DR
GATE enhances Graph Attention Networks by reducing unnecessary neighborhood aggregation, improving performance on heterophilic datasets and enabling deeper architectures without over-smoothing.
Contribution
We introduce GATE, a GAT extension that mitigates over-smoothing, allows deeper networks, and improves performance on heterophilic data by down-weighting irrelevant neighbors.
Findings
GATE reduces over-smoothing in GATs.
GATE outperforms GATs on heterophilic datasets.
Synthetic tests show GATE's ability to control neighborhood aggregation.
Abstract
Graph Attention Networks (GATs) are designed to provide flexible neighborhood aggregation that assigns weights to neighbors according to their importance. In practice, however, GATs are often unable to switch off task-irrelevant neighborhood aggregation, as we show experimentally and analytically. To address this challenge, we propose GATE, a GAT extension that holds three major advantages: i) It alleviates over-smoothing by addressing its root cause of unnecessary neighborhood aggregation. ii) Similarly to perceptrons, it benefits from higher depth as it can still utilize additional layers for (non-)linear feature transformations in case of (nearly) switched-off neighborhood aggregation. iii) By down-weighting connections to unrelated neighbors, it often outperforms GATs on real-world heterophilic datasets. To further validate our claims, we construct a synthetic test bed to analyze a…
Peer Reviews
Decision·ICML 2024 Poster
1. This paper is well-written and easy to follow. The organization of this paper is good. 2. The experiments are comprehensive and the theoretical analyses are solid, which makes the good performance of GATE convincing. 3. It is an interesting and novel idea to switch off task-irrelevant neighborhood aggregation for GATs.
1. It seems that GATE switches off task-irrelevant neighborhood by separating the parameters $a_t$ of the target nodes from $a_s$ of the source nodes. By this, the effect of target nodes is decreased by tuning $a_t$. The question is, when a neighborhood is switched off, all nodes in this neighborhood including those that are helpful to the task are synchronously switched off. Will this be harmful to the model's performance? 2. GATE is able to reduce the performance drop caused by increased depth
1. The research problem is interesting and the proposed method is simple yet effective. 2. The proposed GATE has sufficient theoretical guarantee.
1. I am a little bit worrying about the motivation of this work. In the introduction, the authors claim that an effective attention mechanism should be able to block messages passed from heterophilic neighbors and constitute the remainder of this paper following this claim. However, the scenario described is only one demonstration of a successful attention mechanism. I believe that as long as the attention mechanism can project node of the same class into the similar regions on the decision mani
The paper is well-written and easy to follow. The proposed method is well-motivated and well-described. The GNN operator, which aggregates only relevant neighbors, is a very important component in learning graph representation. The implementation is simple but effective in real-world heterophilous benchmarks.
- If I understand correctly, there is a logical flaw in theoretical results. Can the authors explain the theoretical result more (conservation of norms → small ‘relative’ contributions of attention)? Why is ‘switching off neighborhood aggregation’ related to [αij/αii << 1] rather than [αij << 1]? Regardless of the self-loop, if there are large attention values in the other neighbors than j, wouldn't αij be small? The separation of attention parameters for self-loops and neighbors clearly affects
Code & Models
Videos
No videos yet. Explain this paper in a talk, walkthrough, or lecture? Add one.
Taxonomy
TopicsAdvanced Graph Neural Networks · Domain Adaptation and Few-Shot Learning · Explainable Artificial Intelligence (XAI)
MethodsGraph Attention Network
