Stepping into the Forest: Confronting Interacting Radiation Models for the Hubble Tension with Lyman-$\alpha$ Data

TL;DR

This paper tests models of interacting dark radiation against large-scale structure data, finding that while simple models improve the Hubble tension, they conflict with Ly$ ext{-} ext{alpha}$ data, but more complex models can address both tensions.

Contribution

It evaluates the impact of DM-DR interaction models on LSS and Ly$ ext{-} ext{alpha}$ data, identifying their strengths and limitations in resolving cosmological tensions.

Findings

Simple dark radiation models worsen Ly$ ext{-} ext{alpha}$ fit.

DM-DR interaction models can address both Hubble and $S_8$ tensions.

Ly$ ext{-} ext{alpha}$ data prefer a steeper matter power spectrum slope.

Abstract

Models of interacting dark radiation have been shown to alleviate the Hubble tension. Extensions incorporating a coupling between dark matter and dark radiation (DM-DR) have been proposed as combined solutions to both the Hubble and $S_8$ tensions. A key feature of these extended models is a break in the matter power spectrum (MPS), suppressing power for modes that enter the horizon before the DM-DR interactions turn off. In scenarios with a massless mediator, modes that enter before matter-radiation equality get suppressed, whereas for massive mediators, the break is determined by the mediator mass, a free parameter. In this work, we test these models against probes of LSS: weak lensing, CMB lensing, full-shape galaxy clustering, and eBOSS measurements of the 1D Ly$\alpha\,$ forest flux power spectrum. The latter are the most constraining since they probe small scales where many models predict the largest deviations. In fact, already within $\Lambda{\rm CDM}\,$, the eBOSS Ly$\alpha\,$ data are in significant tension with Planck CMB data, with the Ly$\alpha\,$ data preferring a steeper slope of the MPS at $k \sim h \mathrm{Mpc}^{-1}$. We find that the simplest dark radiation models, which improve the Hubble tension, worsen the fit to the Ly$\alpha\,$ data. However, models with DM-DR interactions can simultaneously address both tensions.