Training-free Editioning of Text-to-Image Models
Jinqi Wang, Yunfei Fu, Zhangcan Ding, Bailin Deng, Yu-Kun Lai, Yipeng, Qin

TL;DR
This paper introduces a training-free method for creating customized editions of text-to-image models by manipulating their latent space representations, enabling targeted image generation without retraining.
Contribution
The paper proposes a novel approach to model editioning using concept subspaces in the latent space, achieved through PCA, allowing flexible customization without retraining.
Findings
Effective creation of model editions via concept subspaces.
Enables targeted image generation for specific user needs.
Demonstrates broad applicability across domains.
Abstract
Inspired by the software industry's practice of offering different editions or versions of a product tailored to specific user groups or use cases, we propose a novel task, namely, training-free editioning, for text-to-image models. Specifically, we aim to create variations of a base text-to-image model without retraining, enabling the model to cater to the diverse needs of different user groups or to offer distinct features and functionalities. To achieve this, we propose that different editions of a given text-to-image model can be formulated as concept subspaces in the latent space of its text encoder (e.g., CLIP). In such a concept subspace, all points satisfy a specific user need (e.g., generating images of a cat lying on the grass/ground/falling leaves). Technically, we apply Principal Component Analysis (PCA) to obtain the desired concept subspaces from representative text…
Peer Reviews
Decision·Submitted to ICLR 2025
- This paper aims to introduce a new type of task that ignores subjects in the text prompts while only editing a predefined concept (e.g., cat). - This paper analyzes the PCA space in CLIP text encoder embedding and achieves image editioning. - Several experiments and interesting observations are made for this new task and the proposed method.
- The image editioning setup is a bit weird to me. If I would like to only generate specific objects, why not just replace the original object's name with the desired concept? An LLM could easily be used for that purpose. The practical value of the proposed method should be better explained. - Different editions require the same computations, and I do not see why different editions should charge differently as illustrated in Figure 1. I have a hard time figuring out why this task could stimula
a.The proposed method is simple but effective. The author propose a novel task for offering different editions or versions of a product tailored to specific user groups or use cases, which may be useful in the software industry’s practice. b.The author conducts extensive experiments and proves its effectiveness.
a. The proposed method, while eliminating the need for model retraining, still requires the creation of a desired concept dataset in advance, which somewhat restricts its applications. b. The presentation of method part is not very clear, especially Figure 3 and I didn’t find its citation in the main text. c.What if I need some concepts that are rare or even not included in the pre-prepared dataset? d.What if I want to generate images with multiple concepts rather than a single concept? e
Overall, the reviewer appreciates the efforts in defining a new task for T2I applications, which genuinely will shed some new light on the research field. Despite much research that has tried to generate/find desired textual prompts for different goals, this is the first time the reviewer has considered controlling the output of T2I models by projecting the textual prompts. The proposed method, though somewhat straightforward, is reasonable. The discussions on Sec.3.1 are also welcomed.
1. Limited scope. Though the authors have tried their best to show the potential applications for the newly proposed task, the reviewer is not convinced that the proposed solution will be widely used in the T2I community. In what situation could we need to force a T2I service to generate only "cat" images while "must not" other concepts? For concept erasing or model aligning, the goal is clear and easy to achieve by listing unwanted concepts. Then, most of the common concepts would work as usual
Videos
No videos yet. Explain this paper in a talk, walkthrough, or lecture? Add one.
Taxonomy
TopicsComputer Graphics and Visualization Techniques · 3D Modeling in Geospatial Applications
Methodstravel james · Balanced Selection
