Unveiling the Impact of Sulfur Doping on Copper-Substituted Lead Apatite: A Theoretical Study

TL;DR

This theoretical study investigates how sulfur doping affects the stability, copper distribution, and electronic properties of copper-substituted lead apatite, providing insights into its potential as a room-temperature superconductor.

Contribution

It systematically analyzes the thermodynamic stability and electronic effects of sulfur doping in Cu-substituted lead apatite, highlighting sulfur's role in facilitating copper doping.

Findings

Pb10-xCux(PO4)6S is thermodynamically stable

Sulfur influences copper distribution but has minor electronic impact

Copper primarily determines electronic properties after synthesis

Abstract

Room-temperature superconductivity represents a significant scientific milestone, with the initial report of LK-99, a copper-substituted lead apatite $\mathrm{Pb}_{10-x}\mathrm{Cu}_{x}(\mathrm{PO}_{4})_{6}\mathrm{O}$, offering a potential breakthrough. However, other researchers have encountered numerous challenges in replicating the original experimental results. In recent studies, Wang et al. successfully observed signs of a possible superconducting phase, such as smaller resistance and stronger diamagnetism, upon doping S into the samples. This indicates that the introduction of S is of significant importance for achieving an appropriate structure. To further investigate the role of S, we have considered the $\mathrm{Pb}_{10-x}\mathrm{Cu}_{x}(\mathrm{PO}_{4})_{6}\mathrm{S}$, systematically discussing its thermodynamic stability, as well as the influence of S on the distribution, concentration, and electronic properties of Cu. We find that $\mathrm{Pb}_{10-x}\mathrm{Cu}_{x}(\mathrm{PO}_{4})_{6}\mathrm{S}$ maintains thermodynamic stability, with S primarily influencing the distribution of Cu. The critical element dictating the electronic characteristics of the material post-synthesis is Cu, while the impact of S on the electronic properties is relatively minor. Our work provides valuable insights into the synthesis of potential apatite based room-temperature superconductors and the role of S in facilitating Cu doping.