Physics of a granular pile

TL;DR

This paper develops a thermodynamic and rheological framework for static granular media by analyzing a 2D granular pile, revealing unique temperature characteristics and the hyperbolic nature of displacement fields, advancing understanding of granular physics.

Contribution

It introduces a first-principles thermodynamic and rheological model for static granular piles, uncovering multiple temperatures and the hyperbolic to elliptic transition in force and displacement fields.

Findings

Granular pile characterized by three distinct temperatures.

Displacement fields exhibit hyperbolic behavior, while force deviations can alter this to elliptic.

The model explains force chains and rheological properties of static granular media.

Abstract

From the onset of the subject, granular media have been defying the toolkit of statistical mechanics thus preventing from understanding their thermodynamical and rheological properties and making them one of the key remaining mysteries in science. In the present work, we offer a resolution to this problem in the case of static granular media by considering a collective behavior of 2D identical balls forming a granular pile in the gravity field, which allows us to develop its thermodynamics and rheology from the first principles. Besides the uncertainty due to rough substrate on which the pile is built, we uncover another one due to ambiguities occurring in the positions of some interior balls. Both are responsible for the thermodynamic description of the granular pile, which proves to be anything but ordinary. In particular, we show that a pile is characterized by three temperatures: one is infinite, the other is negative, and the third is of higher-order. Also, considering the fields of ball displacements $\boldsymbol{\xi}$ and the normal force deviations $\delta\boldsymbol{N}$ from the ideal isosceles triangular structure of a regular pile reveals the hyperbolic nature of the $\boldsymbol{\xi}$-field and ability of the $\delta\boldsymbol{N}$-field to change the characteristic type from hyperbolic to elliptic. The latter property not only explains the origin of force chains and provides an adequate description of the rheology of static granular media, but turned out to be instrumental for understanding of granular media thermodynamics. Our model should provide a basis for further grasping of granular media properties, in general.