Scalarisation-based risk concepts for robust multi-objective optimisation

TL;DR

This paper explores how the order of robustification and scalarisation affects solutions in robust multi-objective optimisation, introducing new concepts and demonstrating their practical impact through case studies.

Contribution

It provides a thorough analysis of the effects of operation ordering in robust multi-objective optimisation and introduces the notion of a robust Pareto front and performance metrics.

Findings

Order of operations impacts solution quality

Existing risk concepts can be integrated into the framework

Case studies demonstrate practical benefits

Abstract

Robust optimisation is a well-established framework for optimising functions in the presence of uncertainty. The inherent goal of this problem is to identify a collection of inputs whose outputs are both desirable for the decision maker, whilst also being robust to the underlying uncertainties in the problem. In this work, we study the multi-objective case of this problem. We identify that the majority of all robust multi-objective algorithms rely on two key operations: robustification and scalarisation. Robustification refers to the strategy that is used to account for the uncertainty in the problem. Scalarisation refers to the procedure that is used to encode the relative importance of each objective to a scalar-valued reward. As these operations are not necessarily commutative, the order that they are performed in has an impact on the resulting solutions that are identified and the final decisions that are made. The purpose of this work is to give a thorough exposition on the effects of these different orderings and in particular highlight when one should opt for one ordering over the other. As part of our analysis, we showcase how many existing risk concepts can be integrated into the specification and solution of a robust multi-objective optimisation problem. Besides this, we also demonstrate how one can principally define the notion of a robust Pareto front and a robust performance metric based on our ``robustify and scalarise'' methodology. To illustrate the efficacy of these new ideas, we present two insightful case studies which are based on real-world data sets.