Positivity bounds on electromagnetic properties of media

TL;DR

This paper derives fundamental positivity bounds on the electromagnetic response functions of media based on microcausality and energy absorption principles, constraining low-frequency permittivity and permeability from high-frequency behavior.

Contribution

It establishes new theoretical bounds on electromagnetic properties of media using causality and positivity, extending previous dispersion relation results.

Findings

Bounds on permittivity and permeability at zero frequency.

Relations between low-frequency response and high-frequency imaginary parts.

Improved bounds for non-relativistic media and specific UV assumptions.

Abstract

We study the constraints imposed on the electromagnetic response of general media by microcausality (commutators of local fields vanish outside the light cone) and positivity of the imaginary parts (the medium can only absorb energy from the external field). The equations of motion for the average electromagnetic field in a medium -- the macroscopic Maxwell equations -- can be derived from the in-in effective action and the effect of the medium is encoded in the electric and magnetic permeabilities $\varepsilon(\omega,|\boldsymbol{k}|)$ and $\mu(\omega,|\boldsymbol{k}|)$. Microcausality implies analyticity of the retarded Green's functions when the imaginary part of the $4$-vector $(\omega,\boldsymbol{k})$ lies in forward light cone. With appropriate assumptions about the behavior of the medium at high frequencies one derives dispersion relations, originally studied by Leontovich. In the case of dielectrics these relations, combined with the positivity of the imaginary parts, imply bounds on the low-energy values of the response, $\varepsilon(0,0)$ and $\mu(0,0)$. In particular the quantities $\varepsilon(0,0)-1$ and $\varepsilon(0,0) - 1/\mu(0,0)$ are constrained to be positive and equal to integrals over the imaginary parts of the response. We discuss various improvements of these bounds in the case of non-relativistic media and with additional assumptions about the UV behavior.