Solar Flare Ribbon Fronts. II. Evolution of heating rates in individual flare footpoints

TL;DR

This study uses numerical experiments to investigate the evolution and lifetime of solar flare ribbon fronts, revealing that low flux electron precipitation sustains ribbon front properties and their transition to bright ribbons depends on chromospheric heating.

Contribution

It demonstrates how low flux nonthermal electron injection influences the duration and evolution of flare ribbon fronts in solar flares, providing insights into their physical mechanisms.

Findings

Ribbon front lifetime correlates with duration of low flux electron precipitation.

Harder electron spectra prolong ribbon front properties.

Transition to bright ribbons occurs when chromospheric temperature and density increase.

Abstract

Solar flare ribbon fronts appear ahead of the bright structures that normally characterise solar flares, and can persist for an extended period of time in spatially localised patches before transitioning to `regular' bright ribbons. They likely represent the initial onset of flare energy deposition into the chromosphere. Chromospheric spectra (e.g. He I 10830A and the Mg II near-UV lines) from ribbon fronts exhibit properties rather different to typical flare behaviour. In prior numerical modelling efforts we were unable to reproduce the long lifetime of ribbon fronts. Here we present a series of numerical experiments that are rather simple but which have important implications. We inject a very low flux of nonthermal electrons ($F = 5\times10^{8}$ erg s$^{-1}$ cm$^{-2}$) into the chromosphere for 100 s before ramping up to standard flare energy fluxes $(F = 10^{10-11}$ erg s$^{-1}$ cm$^{-2}$). Synthetic spectra not only sustained their ribbon front-like properties for significantly longer, in the case of harder nonthermal electron spectra the ribbon front behaviour persisted for the entirety of this weak-heating phase. Lengthening or shortening the duration of the weak-heating phase commensurately lengthened or shortened the ribbon front lifetimes. Ribbon fronts transitioned to regular bright ribbons when the upper chromosphere became sufficiently hot and dense, which happened faster for softer nonthermal electron spectra. Thus, the lifetime of flare ribbon fronts are a direct measure of the duration over which a relatively low flux of high energy electrons precipitates to the chromosphere prior to the bombardment of a much larger energy flux.