Merchants of Vulnerabilities: How Bug Bounty Programs Benefit Software Vendors

TL;DR

This paper uses game theory to analyze how bug bounty programs benefit software vendors by increasing profits, enabling earlier releases, and incentivizing ethical hackers to find vulnerabilities, ultimately improving security.

Contribution

It introduces a game-theoretic model to explain the strategic interactions in bug bounty programs and their impact on vendor profits, release timing, and hacker incentives.

Findings

Vendors increase profits by participating in BBPs.

BBPs lead to earlier software releases with more vulnerabilities.

Higher bounties motivate ethical hackers to find severe vulnerabilities first.

Abstract

Software vulnerabilities enable exploitation by malicious hackers, compromising systems and data security. This paper examines bug bounty programs (BBPs) that incentivize ethical hackers to discover and responsibly disclose vulnerabilities to software vendors. Using game-theoretic models, we capture the strategic interactions between software vendors, ethical hackers, and malicious hackers. First, our analysis shows that software vendors can increase expected profits by participating in BBPs, explaining their growing adoption and the success of BBP platforms. Second, we find that vendors with BBPs will release software earlier, albeit with more potential vulnerabilities, as BBPs enable coordinated vulnerability disclosure and mitigation. Third, the optimal number of ethical hackers to invite to a BBP depends solely on the expected number of malicious hackers seeking exploitation. This optimal number of ethical hackers is lower than but increases with the expected malicious hacker count. Finally, higher bounties incentivize ethical hackers to exert more effort, thereby increasing the probability that they will discover severe vulnerabilities first while reducing the success probability of malicious hackers. These findings highlight BBPs' potential benefits for vendors beyond profitability. Earlier software releases are enabled by managing risks through coordinated disclosure. As cybersecurity threats evolve, BBP adoption will likely gain momentum, providing vendors with a valuable tool for enhancing security posture and stakeholder trust. Moreover, BBPs envelop vulnerability identification and disclosure into new market relationships and transactions, impacting software vendors' incentives regarding product security choices like release timing.