Dynamical formation of Gaia BH3 in the progenitor globular cluster of the ED-2 stream

TL;DR

This paper investigates the dynamical formation of the Gaia BH3 black hole binary within a globular cluster progenitor of the ED-2 stream, using Monte Carlo models to explore cluster properties and black hole retention.

Contribution

It demonstrates that Gaia BH3 likely originated from a low-mass globular cluster that retained many black holes and dissolved to form the ED-2 stream, providing new insights into black hole formation in clusters.

Findings

A low-mass (~10^5 M_sun) globular cluster can produce and retain black hole binaries.

Approximately 75% of black hole binaries are ejected early, while 25% remain in streams.

Galactic halo contains about 10^5 black hole binaries formed in clusters, detectable by Gaia.

Abstract

Context. The star-black hole (S-BH) binary known as Gaia BH3, discovered by the Gaia Collaboration is chemically and kinematically associated with the metal-poor ED-2 stream in the Milky Way halo. Aims. We explore the possibility that Gaia BH3 was assembled dynamically in the progenitor globular cluster (GC) of the ED-2 stream. Methods. We used a public suite of star-by-star dynamical Monte Carlo models to identify S-BH binaries in GCs with different initial masses and (half-mass) radii. Results. We show that a likely progenitor of the ED-2 stream was a relatively low-mass ($\lesssim10^5M_\odot$) GC with an initial half-mass radius of ~4 pc. Such a GC can dynamically retain a large fraction of its BH population and dissolve on the orbit of ED-2. From the suite of models we find that GCs produce ~ 3 - 30 S-BH binaries, approximately independent of initial GC mass and inversely correlated with initial cluster radius. Scaling the results to the Milky Way GC population, we find that ~75% of the S-BH binaries formed in GCs are ejected from their host GC, all in the early phases of evolution ($\lesssim1$ Gyr); these are expected to no longer be close to streams. The ~25% of S-BH binaries retained until dissolution are expected to form part of streams, such that for an initial mass of the progenitor of ED-2 of a few $10^4M_\odot$, we expect ~2-3 S-BH to end up in the stream. GC models with metallicities similar to Gaia BH3 ($\lesssim1\%$ solar) include S-BH binaries with similar BH masses ($\gtrsim30M_\odot$), orbital periods, and eccentricities. Conclusions. We predict the Galactic halo contains of order $10^5$ S-BH binaries that formed dynamically in GCs, a fraction of which may readily be detected in Gaia DR4. The detection of these sources provides valuable tests of BH dynamics in clusters and the possible role in formation of gravitational wave sources.