Uncertain Boundaries: Multidisciplinary Approaches to Copyright Issues in Generative AI

TL;DR

This paper presents a multidisciplinary survey on copyright issues in generative AI, analyzing legal, technical, and economic aspects, and proposing strategies for regulation, detection, and protection of creative works.

Contribution

It synthesizes insights from law, policy, economics, and computer science to address copyright challenges in generative AI, offering comprehensive strategies and technical solutions.

Findings

Identifies key legal and technical challenges in AI copyright issues.

Proposes methods for detecting and preventing copyright infringement.

Suggests regulatory and technical strategies for safeguarding creative works.

Abstract

Generative AI is becoming increasingly prevalent in creative fields, sparking urgent debates over how current copyright laws can keep pace with technological innovation. Recent controversies of AI models generating near-replicas of copyrighted material highlight the need to adapt current legal frameworks and develop technical methods to mitigate copyright infringement risks. This task requires understanding the intersection between computational concepts such as large-scale data scraping and probabilistic content generation, legal definitions of originality and fair use, and economic impacts on IP rights holders. However, most existing research on copyright in AI takes a purely computer science or law-based approach, leaving a gap in coordinating these approaches that only multidisciplinary efforts can effectively address. To bridge this gap, our survey adopts a comprehensive approach synthesizing insights from law, policy, economics, and computer science. It begins by discussing the foundational goals and considerations that should be applied to copyright in generative AI, followed by methods for detecting and assessing potential violations in AI system outputs. Next, it explores various regulatory options influenced by legal, policy, and economic frameworks to manage and mitigate copyright concerns associated with generative AI and reconcile the interests of IP rights holders with that of generative AI producers. The discussion then introduces techniques to safeguard individual creative works from unauthorized replication, such as watermarking and cryptographic protections. Finally, it describes advanced training strategies designed to prevent AI models from reproducing protected content. In doing so, we highlight key opportunities for action and offer actionable strategies that creators, developers, and policymakers can use in navigating the evolving copyright landscape.