Analysis of BMR tilt from AutoTAB catalog: Hinting towards the thin flux tube model?

TL;DR

This study evaluates the thin flux tube model for bipolar magnetic regions (BMRs) on the Sun by analyzing AutoTAB tracked data, revealing flux-dependent behaviors and supporting the role of Coriolis force in BMR tilt formation.

Contribution

It provides empirical evidence linking BMR flux levels to tilt behavior and turbulence effects, testing the validity of the thin flux tube model with observational data.

Findings

Polarity separation increases with BMR lifetime.

Tilt angle correlates with BMR flux, influenced by magnetic buoyancy and drag.

Joy's law dependence observed from first detection of BMRs.

Abstract

One of the intriguing mechanisms of the Sun is the formation of the bipolar magnetic regions (BMRs) in the solar convection zone which are observed as regions of concentrated magnetic fields of opposite polarity on photosphere. These BMRs are tilted with respect to the equatorial line, which statistically increases with latitude. The thin flux tube model, employing the rise of magnetically buoyant flux loops and their twist by Coriolis force, is a popular paradigm for explaining the formation of tilted BMRs. In this study, we assess the validity of the thin flux tube model by analyzing the tracked BMR data obtained through the Automatic Tracking Algorithm for BMRs (AutoTAB). Our observations reveal that the tracked BMRs exhibit the expected collective behaviors. We find that the polarity separation of BMRs increases over their normalized lifetime, supporting the assumption of a rising flux tube from the CZ. Moreover, we observe an increasing trend of the tilt with the flux of the BMR, suggesting that rising flux tubes associated with lower flux regions are primarily influenced by drag force and Coriolis force, while in higher flux regions, magnetic buoyancy dominates. Furthermore, we observe Joy's law dependence for emerging BMRs from their first detection, indicating that at least a portion of the tilt observed in BMRs can be attributed to the Coriolis force. Notably, lower flux regions exhibit a higher amount of fluctuations associated with their tilt measurement compared to stronger flux regions, suggesting that lower flux regions are more susceptible to turbulent convection.