X-ray and molecular dynamics study of the temperature-dependent structure of molten NaF-ZrF4

TL;DR

This study combines x-ray scattering and advanced molecular dynamics simulations to analyze the temperature-dependent atomic structure of molten NaF-ZrF4, revealing complex coordination dynamics and structural transitions with increasing temperature.

Contribution

It introduces machine-learning enhanced neural network molecular dynamics for efficient, accurate analysis of molten salt structures over a temperature range, highlighting coordination changes and structural metastability.

Findings

Identification of three fluorozirconate complexes with temperature-dependent dominance.

Observation of a shift towards 6-coordinated Zr ions at higher temperatures.

Detection of both edge-sharing and corner-sharing fluorozirconate complexes.

Abstract

The local atomic structure of NaF-ZrF$_4$ (53-47 mol%) molten system and its evolution with temperature are examined with x-ray scattering measurements and compared with $ab-initio$ and Neural Network-based molecular dynamics (NNMD) simulations in the temperature range 515-700 {\deg}C. The machine-learning enhanced NNMD calculations offer improved efficiency while maintaining accuracy at higher distances compared to ab-initio calculations. Looking at the evolution of the Pair Distribution Function with increasing temperature, a fundamental change in the liquid structure within the selected temperature range, accompanied by a slight decrease in overall correlation is revealed. NNMD calculations indicate the co-existence of three different fluorozirconate complexes: [ZrF$_6$]$^{2-}$, [ZrF$_7$]$^{3-}$, and [ZrF$_8$]$^{4-}$, with a temperature-dependent shift in the dominant coordination state towards a 6-coordinated Zr ion at 700{\deg}C. The study also highlights the metastability of different coordination structures, with frequent interconversions between 6 and 7 coordinate states for the fluorozirconate complex from 525 {\deg}C to 700 {\deg}C. Analysis of the Zr-F-Zr angular distribution function reveals the presence of both $"$edge-sharing$"$ and $"$corner-sharing$"$ fluorozirconate complexes with specific bond angles and distances in accord with previous studies, while the next-nearest neighbor cation-cation correlations demonstrate a clear preference for unlike cations as nearest-neighbor pairs, emphasizing non-random arrangement. These findings contribute to a comprehensive understanding of the complex local structure of the molten salt, providing insights into temperature-dependent preferences and correlations within the molten system.