Confirmation of the centrality of the Huanan market among early COVID-19 cases

TL;DR

This study reaffirms the Huanan market's central role in early COVID-19 cases by correcting statistical assumptions and demonstrating that the market remains a plausible source, contrary to recent challenges.

Contribution

The paper refutes recent statistical criticisms by demonstrating proper application of methods, reaffirming the market's centrality with comprehensive evidence.

Findings

The mode is the appropriate measure of centrality for the data.

Proper implementation shows the mode at the market entrance.

The market's location is within the 95% confidence region.

Abstract

The centrality of Wuhan's Huanan market in maps of December 2019 COVID-19 case residential locations, established by Worobey et al. (2022a), has recently been challenged by Stoyan and Chiu (2024, SC2024). SC2024 proposed a statistical test based on the premise that the measure of central tendency (hereafter, "centre") of a sample of case locations must coincide with the exact point from which local transmission began. Here we show that this premise is erroneous. SC2024 put forward two alternative centres (centroid and mode) to the centre-point which was used by Worobey et al. for some analyses, and proposed a bootstrapping method, based on their premise, to test whether a particular location is consistent with it being the point source of transmission. We show that SC2024's concerns about the use of centre-points are inconsequential, and that use of centroids for these data is inadvisable. The mode is an appropriate, even optimal, choice as centre; however, contrary to SC2024's results, we demonstrate that with proper implementation of their methods, the mode falls at the entrance of a parking lot at the market itself, and the 95% confidence region around the mode includes the market. Thus, the market cannot be rejected as central even by SC2024's overly stringent statistical test. Our results directly contradict SC2024's and -- together with myriad additional lines of evidence overlooked by SC2024, including crucial epidemiological information -- point to the Huanan market as the early epicentre of the COVID-19 pandemic.