A 3D picture of moist-convection inhibition in hydrogen-rich atmospheres: Implications for K2-18 b

TL;DR

This study uses 3D modeling to explore moist convection in hydrogen-rich atmospheres of Neptune-like exoplanets, revealing convection shutdown, stable layers, and implications for potential liquid oceans on K2-18b.

Contribution

Developed a 3D cloud resolving model for H2 atmospheres with condensables, confirming convection shutdown and creating a simplified 1D model for Neptune-like planets.

Findings

Moist convection shuts down above certain condensable abundances.

Stable stratified layers lead to hotter deep atmospheres.

High albedo is required for liquid oceans, but observational data contradicts this.

Abstract

While small, Neptune-like planets are among the most abundant exoplanets, our understanding of their atmospheric structure and dynamics remains sparse. In particular, many unknowns remain on the way moist convection works in these atmospheres where condensable species are heavier than the non-condensable background gas. While it has been predicted that moist convection could shut-down above some threshold abundance of these condensable species, this prediction is based on simple linear analysis and relies on strong assumptions on the saturation of the atmosphere. To investigate this issue, we develop a 3D cloud resolving model for H2 atmospheres with large amounts of condensable species and apply this model to a prototypical temperate Neptune-like planet -- K2-18b. Our model confirms the shut-down of moist convection and the onset of a stably stratified layer in the atmosphere, leading to much hotter deep atmospheres and interiors. Our 3D simulations further provide quantitative estimates of the turbulent mixing in this stable layer, which is a key driver of the cycling of condensables in the atmosphere. This allows us to build a very simple, yet realistic 1D model that captures the most salient features of the structure of Neptune-like atmospheres. Our qualitative findings on the behavior of moist convection in hydrogen atmospheres go beyond temperate planets and should also apply to the regions where iron and silicates condense in the deep interior of H2-dominated planets. Finally, we use our model to investigate the likelihood of a liquid ocean beneath a H2 dominated atmosphere on K2-18b. We find that the planet would need to have a very high albedo (>0.5-0.6) to sustain a liquid ocean. However, due to the spectral type of the star, the amount of aerosol scattering that would be needed to provide such a high albedo is inconsistent with the latest observational data.