Limitations of Data-Driven Spectral Reconstruction -- An Optics-Aware Analysis

TL;DR

This paper critically examines the limitations of data-driven spectral reconstruction from RGB images, highlighting dataset issues, fundamental spectral ambiguities, and potential optical encoding strategies, emphasizing the need for better datasets for progress.

Contribution

It systematically analyzes overfitting, dataset limitations, and optical encoding strategies, revealing fundamental challenges and proposing directions for future spectral imaging improvements.

Findings

Data-driven methods overfit current datasets and struggle with unseen data.

RGB spectral reconstruction cannot reliably handle metameric conditions.

Optical encoding strategies offer limited improvements due to dataset issues.

Abstract

Hyperspectral imaging empowers machine vision systems with the distinct capability of identifying materials through recording their spectral signatures. Recent efforts in data-driven spectral reconstruction aim at extracting spectral information from RGB images captured by cost-effective RGB cameras, instead of dedicated hardware. Published work reports exceedingly high numerical scores for this reconstruction task, yet real-world performance lags substantially behind. We systematically analyze the performance of such methods. First, we evaluate the overfitting limitations with respect to current datasets by training the networks with less data, validating the trained models with unseen yet slightly modified data and cross-dataset validation. Second, we reveal fundamental limitations in the ability of RGB to spectral methods to deal with metameric or near-metameric conditions, which have so far gone largely unnoticed due to the insufficiencies of existing datasets. We validate the trained models with metamer data generated by metameric black theory and re-training the networks with various forms of metamers. This methodology can also be used for data augmentation as a partial mitigation of the dataset issues, although the RGB to spectral inverse problem remains fundamentally ill-posed. Finally, we analyze the potential for modifying the problem setting to achieve better performance by exploiting optical encoding provided by either optical aberrations or deliberate optical design. Our experiments show such approaches provide improved results under certain circumstances, but their overall performance is limited by the same dataset issues. We conclude that future progress on snapshot spectral imaging will heavily depend on the generation of improved datasets which can then be used to design effective optical encoding strategies. Code: https://github.com/vccimaging/OpticsAwareHSI-Analysis.