Best practices for machine learning in antibody discovery and development

TL;DR

This paper reviews current ML practices in antibody discovery, identifies challenges, and proposes standardized guidelines to improve reproducibility and accelerate therapeutic antibody development.

Contribution

It provides a comprehensive critique of existing ML methods in antibody D&D and offers a set of best practices and evaluation guidelines for the field.

Findings

Highlights diversity in datasets and evaluation metrics hampers comparison

Identifies common pitfalls in ML-based antibody discovery

Recommends standardized protocols for ML model development and assessment

Abstract

Over the past 40 years, the discovery and development of therapeutic antibodies to treat disease has become common practice. However, as therapeutic antibody constructs are becoming more sophisticated (e.g., multi-specifics), conventional approaches to optimisation are increasingly inefficient. Machine learning (ML) promises to open up an in silico route to antibody discovery and help accelerate the development of drug products using a reduced number of experiments and hence cost. Over the past few years, we have observed rapid developments in the field of ML-guided antibody discovery and development (D&D). However, many of the results are difficult to compare or hard to assess for utility by other experts in the field due to the high diversity in the datasets and evaluation techniques and metrics that are across industry and academia. This limitation of the literature curtails the broad adoption of ML across the industry and slows down overall progress in the field, highlighting the need to develop standards and guidelines that may help improve the reproducibility of ML models across different research groups. To address these challenges, we set out in this perspective to critically review current practices, explain common pitfalls, and clearly define a set of method development and evaluation guidelines that can be applied to different types of ML-based techniques for therapeutic antibody D&D. Specifically, we address in an end-to-end analysis, challenges associated with all aspects of the ML process and recommend a set of best practices for each stage.