On the nature of Nova 1670 (CK Vulpeculae): a merger of a red giant with a helium white dwarf

TL;DR

This paper investigates Nova 1670, a stellar merger event, proposing it resulted from a red giant merging with a helium white dwarf, leading to unique chemical signatures and evolution towards an R-type carbon star.

Contribution

It provides the first detailed analysis of the progenitor system of Nova 1670, combining observations and simulations to identify the merger as between a red giant and a helium white dwarf.

Findings

Progenitor was a 1-2 solar mass red giant.

Merger involved a helium white dwarf, with about 12% of energy from He burning.

Remnant resembles early R-type carbon stars.

Abstract

Nova 1670 is a historical transient bearing strong similarities to a recently-recognized type of stellar eruptions known as red novae, which are thought to be powered by stellar mergers. The remnant of the transient, CK Vul, is observable today mainly through cool circumstellar gas and dust, and recombining plasma, but we have no direct view on the stellar object. Within the merger hypothesis, we aim to infer the most likely makeup of the progenitor system that resulted in Nova 1670. We collect and summarize the literature data on the physical properties of the outburst and the remnant, and on the chemical composition of the circumstellar material which resulted from optical and submillimeter observations of the circumstellar gas of CK Vul. Simple simulations yield the form and level of mixing of material associated with the merger. Products of nuclear burning are identified, among them ashes of H burning in the CNO cycles and the MgAl chain, as well as of partial He burning. Based on the luminosity and chemical composition of the remnant, we find that the progenitor primary had to be an evolutionarily advanced red-giant branch star of a mass of 1-2 M$_{\odot}$. The secondary was either a very similar giant, or a He white dwarf. While the eruption event was mainly powered by accretion, we estimate that about 12% of total energy might have come from He burning activated during the merger. The coalescence of a first-ascent giant with a He white dwarf created a star with a rather unique internal structure and composition, which resemble these of early R-type carbon stars. Nova 1670 was the result of a merger between a He white dwarf and a first-ascent red giant and is likely now evolving to become an early R-type carbon star.