Sorting Out Quantum Monte Carlo
Jack Richter-Powell, Luca Thiede, Al\'an Asparu-Guzik, David Duvenaud

TL;DR
This paper introduces a scalable antisymmetrization method called 'sortlet' for quantum Monte Carlo simulations, enabling efficient wavefunction parameterization that achieves chemical accuracy for small molecules.
Contribution
The paper presents a novel antisymmetrization layer based on sorting, called 'sortlet', which reduces computational complexity from O(N^3) to O(N log N) for fermionic wavefunctions.
Findings
Sortlet scales as O(N log N), significantly faster than traditional determinants.
Applying sortlet on neural networks achieves chemical accuracy in small molecules.
The method is effective for approximating ground states of first-row atoms.
Abstract
Molecular modeling at the quantum level requires choosing a parameterization of the wavefunction that both respects the required particle symmetries, and is scalable to systems of many particles. For the simulation of fermions, valid parameterizations must be antisymmetric with respect to the exchange of particles. Typically, antisymmetry is enforced by leveraging the anti-symmetry of determinants with respect to the exchange of matrix rows, but this involves computing a full determinant each time the wavefunction is evaluated. Instead, we introduce a new antisymmetrization layer derived from sorting, the , which scales as with regards to the number of particles -- in contrast to for the determinant. We show numerically that applying this anti-symmeterization layer on top of an attention based neural-network backbone yields a flexible…
Peer Reviews
Decision·Submitted to ICLR 2024
It is interesting to design an ansatz with favorable computational complexity.
1. To the reviewer’s best knowledge, the sorting algorithm in 3-dimensional space (more concretely, any spaces where the dimension is larger than one) is discontinuous. Thus, the proposed ansatz is discontinuous. When calculating the kinetic energy term, it is hard for the mcmc walkers to handle the energy near the discontinuous surface. As a result, the conventional energy calculation method in NN-VMC will lead to a non-variational energy result, which means the energy of the proposed method ca
The following paper considers a challenging topic of removing the dependency on the Slater determinant and by that trying to improve the scaling of recently proposed deep-learning-based wavefunction ansätze. Beside the anti-symmetry constrain of the wavefunction another complexity of the problem at hand is the need for highly accurate solutions. Normally, DL-VMC tries to recover the last 1-2mHa of the total energy. Therefore, the following paper has in my opinion three key strength: - Novelty
One concern I have is regarding the claimed scaling of O(N log N) in the abstract. As stated in Sec. 3.1. it is more in the realm of O(N^2 log N) if not worse (see Fig. 3a). A more detailed discussion about the need of expansions (K) would help improve the paper. With the current results it is difficult for me to assess if the scaling is actually as proposed. Although the paper motivates the problem and I am fine with the general structure of the paper, I have problems with the notation and e
The paper is well written and the proposed method clearly described. The section on variational quantum Monte Carlo is an excellent introduction for readers without a quantum chemistry education and makes the topic very approachable.
The proposed sortlet ansatz is only tested on very small systems. It performs significantly worse compared to the standard determinant-based ansatz for systems as small as the nitrogen atom (7 electrons). While the authors admit that this is the case ("our results are far from competitive with those of neural network ansatz with full determinant"), I do not agree with their statement that the proof-of-concept described in this paper is sufficient evidence that the sortlet ansatz is a promising d
Videos
No videos yet. Explain this paper in a talk, walkthrough, or lecture? Add one.
Taxonomy
TopicsMachine Learning in Materials Science · Advanced Chemical Physics Studies · Advanced NMR Techniques and Applications
