MgNO: Efficient Parameterization of Linear Operators via Multigrid
Juncai He, Xinliang Liu, Jinchao Xu

TL;DR
MgNO introduces a multigrid-based neural operator architecture that efficiently parameterizes linear operators, achieving superior training ease, reduced overfitting, and state-of-the-art PDE solving performance.
Contribution
The paper presents MgNO, a novel neural operator using multigrid structures for efficient linear operator parameterization, eliminating the need for lifting/projection and handling diverse boundary conditions.
Findings
MgNO outperforms existing models in training ease.
MgNO demonstrates reduced overfitting compared to spectral neural operators.
MgNO achieves state-of-the-art accuracy on various PDE problems.
Abstract
In this work, we propose a concise neural operator architecture for operator learning. Drawing an analogy with a conventional fully connected neural network, we define the neural operator as follows: the output of the -th neuron in a nonlinear operator layer is defined by . Here, denotes the bounded linear operator connecting -th input neuron to -th output neuron, and the bias takes the form of a function rather than a scalar. Given its new universal approximation property, the efficient parameterization of the bounded linear operators between two neurons (Banach spaces) plays a critical role. As a result, we introduce MgNO, utilizing multigrid structures to parameterize these linear operators between neurons. This approach offers both mathematical rigor and practical expressivity. Additionally, MgNO…
Peer Reviews
Decision·ICLR 2024 poster
- The paper is very clearly written, the ideas are solid and the numerics are strong. I like the spirit of an architecture where neurons become operators: this appears very natural and the right thing to do. - Using a multigrid (or in general multiscale) representation of operators is also the right thing to do. Similar ideas go back to efficient wavelet approximations of operators of Beylkin, Coifman, and Rokhlin. It is nice to see this done explicitly and clearly it yields strong performance.
- Many of the ideas might have already been present in MgNet; it would be nice to see a comment. - It is not clear to me what (9) is stating since you don't state the typical values of c. How should we use / interpret (9)? - The motivation via exact encoding of boundary conditions is sound but I would also say quite easy to implement with other neural operators. For example the FNO by default works on the torus but via zero padding could be easily adapted to Neumann or Dirichlet boundaries (th
1. The authors introduced a novel formulation for neural operators that characterizes neuron connections as bounded linear operators within function spaces. This eliminates the need for traditional lifting and projecting operators, simplifying the architecture. 2. The MgNO architecture, which leverages multigrid structure and multi-channel convolutional form, efficiently parameterizes linear operators while accommodating various boundary conditions. This approach enhances both accuracy and effi
The limitations and drawbacks of the proposed methods are not explicitly mentioned
The neural operator proposed in this paper uses the multi-scale method to get a better parameterization of the weights. It is applied to the spatial domain hence it seems like it won't significantly increase the complexity. From the experimental results, MGNO works quite well compared to other models, which provides convincing evidence that MGNO can be useful.
1. I am confused about the discretization of the input. It seems like the input still needs to be discretized (Eq.(6)) and the multigrid is applied to the spatial domain. Then I suppose the performance and the efficiency of MGNO are affected by the mesh size $h=1/d$. The performance of MGNO with respect to $d$ is missing in the paper. 2. What about the parameterization with multi-channel inputs? Can this V-cycle be applied to multi-channel inputs? If there is no easy extension, I believe the si
Videos
Taxonomy
TopicsModel Reduction and Neural Networks · Advanced Numerical Analysis Techniques · Neural Networks and Applications
