Making the cut: end effects and the benefits of slicing

TL;DR

This paper investigates the three-dimensional stress distribution in wire cutting of soft solids, revealing that end effects and slicing can reduce cutting forces under certain conditions, challenging previous planar assumptions.

Contribution

It demonstrates that a 3D analysis is essential for understanding cutting mechanics, showing how end effects influence stress distribution and the role of friction and material properties.

Findings

Maximal tensile stress occurs in the front plane, not the mid-plane.

Friction reduces tensile stress but can be offset by high slice-to-push ratios.

Slicing can lower cutting forces if specific conditions are met.

Abstract

Cutting mechanics in soft solids have been a subject of study for several decades, an interest fuelled by the multitude of its applications, including material testing, manufacturing, and biomedical technology. Wire cutting is the simplest model system to analyze the cutting resistance of a soft material. However, even for this simple system, the complex failure mechanisms that underpin cutting are still not completely understood. Several models that connect the critical cutting force to the radius of the wire and the key mechanical properties of the cut material have been proposed. An almost ubiquitous simplifying assumption is a state of plane (and anti-plane) strain in the material. In this paper, we show that this assumption can lead to erroneous conclusions because even such a simple cutting problem is essentially three-dimensional. A planar approximation restricts the analysis to the stress distribution in the mid-plane. However, through finite element modeling, we reveal that the maximal tensile stress - and thus the likely location of cut initiation - is in fact located in the front plane. Friction reduces the magnitude of this stress, but this detrimental effect can be counteracted by large slice-to-push (shear-to-indentation) ratios. The introduction of these end effects helps reconcile a recent controversy around the role of friction in wire cutting, for it implies that slicing can indeed reduce required cutting forces, but only if the slice-push ratio and the friction coefficient are sufficiently large. Material strain-stiffening reduces the critical indentation depth required to initiate the cut further and thus needs to be considered when cutting non-linearly elastic materials.