Disappearing galaxies: the orientation dependence of JWST-bright, HST-dark, star-forming galaxy selection

TL;DR

This study uses high-resolution simulations to explore the orientation dependence of JWST-bright, HST-dark, star-forming galaxies, revealing that their visibility depends heavily on the line of sight and dust distribution.

Contribution

First simulation-based analysis of HST-dark galaxies, showing their dependence on viewing angle and dust, with implications for observational and theoretical galaxy studies.

Findings

HST-dark galaxies are high-redshift, dust-rich, and compact.

Orientation significantly affects galaxy detectability in optical/NIR.

HST-dark sources are not exotic but a natural subset of dusty, high-z galaxies.

Abstract

Galaxies that are invisible in deep optical-NIR imaging but detected at longer wavelengths have been the focus of several recent observational studies, with speculation that they could constitute a substantial missing population and even dominate the cosmic star formation rate density at $z\gtrsim4$. The depths now achievable with JWST at the longest wavelengths probed by HST, coupled with the transformative resolution at longer wavelengths, are already enabling detailed, spatially-resolved characterisation of sources that were invisible to HST, often known as `HST-dark' galaxies. However, until now, there has been little theoretical work to compare against. We present the first simulation-based study of this population, using highly-resolved galaxies from the Feedback in Realistic Environments (FIRE) project, with multi-wavelength images along several lines of sight forward-modelled using radiative transfer. We naturally recover a population of modelled sources that meet commonly-used selection criteria ($H_{\rm{AB}}>27\,\rm{mag}$ and $H_{\rm{AB}}-\rm{F444W}>2.3$). These simulated HST-dark galaxies lie at high redshifts ($z=4-7$), have high levels of dust attenuation ($A_{V}=2-4$), and display compact recent star formation ($R_{1/2,\,\rm{4.4\,\mu\rm{m}}}\lesssim1\,\rm{kpc}$). Orientation is very important: for all but one of the 17 simulated galaxy snapshots with HST-dark sightlines, there exist other sightlines that do not meet the criteria. This result has important implications for comparisons between observations and models that do not resolve the detailed star-dust geometry, such as semi-analytic models or coarsely-resolved hydrodynamical simulations. Critically, we demonstrate that HST-dark sources are not an unexpected or exotic population, but a subset of high-redshift, highly-dust-attenuated sources viewed along certain lines of sight.