Absence of topological Hall effect in Fe$_x$Rh$_{100-x}$ epitaxial films: revisiting their phase diagram

TL;DR

This study systematically investigates Fe$_x$Rh$_{100-x}$ epitaxial films, revisiting their magnetic phase diagram and Hall effects, and finds no evidence of topological Hall effect, suggesting previous observations were likely extrinsic.

Contribution

The paper provides a comprehensive analysis of Fe$_x$Rh$_{100-x}$ films, clarifying their phase transitions and Hall effects, and challenges previous claims of topological Hall effect in these materials.

Findings

FM-AFM transition extends over a wider Fe-content range in films.

Absence of topological Hall effect in all studied compositions.

Anomalous Hall effect explained by interface iron moments.

Abstract

A series of Fe$_x$Rh$_{100-x}$ ($30 \leq x \leq 57$) films were epitaxially grown using magnetron sputtering, and were systematically studied by magnetization-, electrical resistivity-, and Hall resistivity measurements. After optimizing the growth conditions, phase-pure Fe$_{x}$Rh$_{100-x}$ films were obtained, and their magnetic phase diagram was revisited. The ferromagnetic (FM) to antiferromagnetic (AFM) transition is limited at narrow Fe-contents with $48 \leq x \leq 54$ in the bulk Fe$_x$Rh$_{100-x}$ alloys. By contrast, the FM-AFM transition in the Fe$_x$Rh$_{100-x}$ films is extended to cover a much wider $x$ range between 33 % and 53 %, whose critical temperature slightly decreases as increasing the Fe-content. The resistivity jump and magnetization drop at the FM-AFM transition are much more significant in the Fe$_x$Rh$_{100-x}$ films with $\sim$50 % Fe-content than in the Fe-deficient films, the latter have a large amount of paramagnetic phase. The magnetoresistivity (MR) is rather weak and positive in the AFM state, while it becomes negative when the FM phase shows up, and a giant MR appears in the mixed FM- and AFM states. The Hall resistivity is dominated by the ordinary Hall effect in the AFM state, while in the mixed state or high-temperature FM state, the anomalous Hall effect takes over. The absence of topological Hall resistivity in Fe$_{x}$Rh$_{100-x}$ films with various Fe-contents implies that the previously observed topological Hall effect is most likely extrinsic. We propose that the anomalous Hall effect caused by the FM iron moments at the interfaces nicely explains the hump-like anomaly in the Hall resistivity. Our systematic investigations may offer valuable insights into the spintronics based on iron-rhodium alloys.