Unraveling the Thermodynamic Enigma between Fast and Slow Coronal Mass Ejections

TL;DR

This study analyzes the thermodynamic evolution of two coronal mass ejections, revealing how their speeds influence heating processes and expansion forces, with implications for space weather understanding.

Contribution

It introduces a detailed thermodynamic analysis of CMEs using the revised FRIS model, linking kinematic differences to heating and expansion behaviors.

Findings

Faster CME exhibits heat-release during early acceleration

Slower CME transitions gradually to heat-absorption state

Expansion driven mainly by centrifugal and thermal forces

Abstract

Coronal Mass Ejections (CMEs) are the most energetic expulsions of magnetized plasma from the Sun that play a crucial role in space weather dynamics. This study investigates the diverse kinematics and thermodynamic evolution of two CMEs (CME1: 2011 September 24 and CME2: 2018 August 20) at coronal heights where thermodynamic measurements are limited. The peak 3D propagation speed of CME1 is high (1,885 km/s) with two-phase expansion (rapid and nearly constant), while the peak 3D propagation speed of CME2 is slow (420 km/s) with only a gradual expansion. We estimate the distance-dependent variations in the polytropic index, heating rate, temperature, and internal forces implementing the revised FRIS model, taking inputs of 3D kinematics estimated from the GCS model. We find CME1 exhibiting heat-release during its early-rapid acceleration decrease and jumps to the heat-absorption state during its constant acceleration phase. In contrast to CME1, CME2 shows a gradual transition from the near-adiabatic to the heat-absorption state during its gradually increasing acceleration. Our analysis reveals that although both CMEs show differential heating, they experience heat-absorption during their later propagation phases, approaching the isothermal state. The faster CME1 achieves an adiabatic state followed by an isothermal state at smaller distances from the Sun than the slower CME2. We also find that the expansion of CMEs is primarily influenced by centrifugal and thermal pressure forces, with the Lorentz force impeding expansion. Multi-wavelength observations of flux-ropes at source regions support the FRIS model-derived findings at initially observed lower coronal heights.