A Plug-and-Play Image Registration Network
Junhao Hu, Weijie Gan, Zhixin Sun, Hongyu An, Ulugbek S. Kamilov

TL;DR
This paper introduces PIRATE, a novel deep learning-based deformable image registration method that explicitly incorporates data fidelity and a CNN prior, with PIRATE+ further enhancing performance through end-to-end training with deep equilibrium models.
Contribution
The paper proposes PIRATE, a plug-and-play framework for image registration that integrates explicit data fidelity and CNN priors, and introduces PIRATE+ with end-to-end training for improved accuracy.
Findings
Achieves state-of-the-art performance on OASIS and CANDI datasets.
Effectively combines data fidelity with learned CNN priors.
Enhances registration accuracy through deep equilibrium model fine-tuning.
Abstract
Deformable image registration (DIR) is an active research topic in biomedical imaging. There is a growing interest in developing DIR methods based on deep learning (DL). A traditional DL approach to DIR is based on training a convolutional neural network (CNN) to estimate the registration field between two input images. While conceptually simple, this approach comes with a limitation that it exclusively relies on a pre-trained CNN without explicitly enforcing fidelity between the registered image and the reference. We present plug-and-play image registration network (PIRATE) as a new DIR method that addresses this issue by integrating an explicit data-fidelity penalty and a CNN prior. PIRATE pre-trains a CNN denoiser on the registration field and "plugs" it into an iterative method as a regularizer. We additionally present PIRATE+ that fine-tunes the CNN prior in PIRATE using deep…
Peer Reviews
Decision·ICLR 2024 poster
The paper seems to be the first at using plug-and-play priors for registration, which could be a useful contribution in this already rich space. The work obtains good quantitative results on standard benchmarks for deformable medical image registration.
My main issue is with the writing and presentation of this paper: - There was virtually no intuitive explanation of what plug-and-play does, why it is useful compared to other approaches, etc. Given that one of the reported contributions of the paper is to show that denoising priors can be used for registration, the lack of any explanation of why denoising is appropriate, how it works, etc. is quite conspicuous. - What is the main drawback with current deformable image registration models tha
+ The proposed method used the DEQ approach for iterative registrations. The adapting approach is unique and reasonable. Their training loss looks going down well on the datasets. + DEQ approach successfully addressed registration problems with PnP(plug-and-play) method with appealing gain in Tables 1 & 2.
+ I didn't understand the motivation of using pre-trained denoisor for regularizations. Why isn't the trainable denoiser used for this task? + No ablation studies about the necessity of the usage of a pre-trained model + Less analysis on the DEQ model : I would like to see the convergence of the number of function evaluation(NFE) along with the training iterations. + In general, the result section is short of significant experiments to support their claim. For example, Figure 3 is a single insta
The proposed methods (PIRATE and PIRATE+) are novel methodological contributions which is positive. Additionally, the proposed framework is compared to a number of different methods, including DL and non-DL methods, which is very good. This also includes the best-performing method from recent comparative studies (Mok and Chung, CVPR 2020, MICCAI 2020). The results reported outperform this method in terms of registration accuracy. Another strength of the paper is the careful review of the state-o
The weaknesses are mainly related to the evaluation of the proposed framework: - The methods compared in the paper use very different loss or cost functions as well as different models for the parameterization of the deformation field. This makes the papers' comparison of the registration accuracy in terms of voxels with negative Jacobian very difficult to come across methods. Registration accuracy measured in terms of Dice is more meaningful. At the same time, it would have been good if the au
Videos
Taxonomy
TopicsMedical Image Segmentation Techniques · Radiomics and Machine Learning in Medical Imaging · Medical Imaging Techniques and Applications
MethodsOASIS
