Beyond Myopia: Learning from Positive and Unlabeled Data through Holistic Predictive Trends

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel holistic trend-based approach for positive and unlabeled learning, leveraging predictive score patterns over time to improve classification accuracy without extra parameter tuning.

Contribution

It proposes a TPP-inspired trend detection method for PUL, addressing bias and error accumulation issues, and demonstrates superior performance in imbalanced real-world scenarios.

Findings

Achieves up to 11.3% improvement in key metrics

Effectively models score trends as temporal point processes

Does not require additional parameter tuning or prior assumptions

Abstract

Learning binary classifiers from positive and unlabeled data (PUL) is vital in many real-world applications, especially when verifying negative examples is difficult. Despite the impressive empirical performance of recent PUL methods, challenges like accumulated errors and increased estimation bias persist due to the absence of negative labels. In this paper, we unveil an intriguing yet long-overlooked observation in PUL: \textit{resampling the positive data in each training iteration to ensure a balanced distribution between positive and unlabeled examples results in strong early-stage performance. Furthermore, predictive trends for positive and negative classes display distinctly different patterns.} Specifically, the scores (output probability) of unlabeled negative examples consistently decrease, while those of unlabeled positive examples show largely chaotic trends. Instead of focusing on classification within individual time frames, we innovatively adopt a holistic approach, interpreting the scores of each example as a temporal point process (TPP). This reformulates the core problem of PUL as recognizing trends in these scores. We then propose a novel TPP-inspired measure for trend detection and prove its asymptotic unbiasedness in predicting changes. Notably, our method accomplishes PUL without requiring additional parameter tuning or prior assumptions, offering an alternative perspective for tackling this problem. Extensive experiments verify the superiority of our method, particularly in a highly imbalanced real-world setting, where it achieves improvements of up to $11.3\%$ in key metrics. The code is available at \href{https://github.com/wxr99/HolisticPU}{https://github.com/wxr99/HolisticPU}.