OpenPatch: a 3D patchwork for Out-Of-Distribution detection
Paolo Rabino, Antonio Alliegro, Francesco Cappio Borlino, Tatiana, Tommasi

TL;DR
OpenPatch introduces a novel 3D patch-based method for out-of-distribution detection in point clouds, leveraging pre-trained models to identify semantic novelties without additional training.
Contribution
It proposes a training-free approach that uses intermediate patch features from pre-trained models to detect semantic novelties in 3D point clouds.
Findings
Outperforms existing methods in semantic novelty detection
Effective in both full and few-shot scenarios
Robust across different pre-training objectives and backbones
Abstract
Moving deep learning models from the laboratory setting to the open world entails preparing them to handle unforeseen conditions. In several applications the occurrence of novel classes during deployment poses a significant threat, thus it is crucial to effectively detect them. Ideally, this skill should be used when needed without requiring any further computational training effort at every new task. Out-of-distribution detection has attracted significant attention in the last years, however the majority of the studies deal with 2D images ignoring the inherent 3D nature of the real-world and often confusing between domain and semantic novelty. In this work, we focus on the latter, considering the objects geometric structure captured by 3D point clouds regardless of the specific domain. We advance the field by introducing OpenPatch that builds on a large pre-trained model and simply…
Peer Reviews
Decision·Submitted to ICLR 2024
OpenPatch's strengths are concentrated in the following areas: (1) Novelty in distinguishing known and unknown classes: OpenPatch introduces a strategy for extracting generalizable patch features from pre-trained 3D deep learning architectures. It devises an innovative approach that integrates semantic and relative distance information to accurately identify new categories during the testing phase. (2) Streamlined deployment: OpenPatch can be efficiently deployed in resource-constrained enviro
(1) About innovation. The approach taken in this paper is too similar to PatchCore. For example, the "Patch Feature Extractor" in OpenPatch mirrors the "Local-Aware Patch Feature" in PatchCore, while the "Memory Bank and Subsampling" in OpenPatch is very similar to the "Coreset Reduced Patch Feature Memory Bank" in PatchCore. And the key strategies selected by the two papers are similar, such as Greedy Coreset and KNN. Overall, I think this paper lacks innovation. (2) About experiments. A. The
Not much could be said here.
1. The importance of determining if the point cloud of an object is out-of-domain for a 3d classifier is not well-presented. No prior works nor possible applications are shown for this work. 2. The authors proposed a patch-based method for determining if a point cloud is OOD but failed to mention how are those patches obtained. I guess how to break a whole point cloud into patches has a significant impact on the OOD recognition accuracy. In this sense, the proposed method is not even complete. 3
- Detection of novel classes is indeed an important task. While many methods have been proposed in 2D, it has been less explored in 3D applications. - The paper is generally clear and easy to understand
- The task of out-of-distribution detection is closely related to the open-set and open-world task. Nonetheless, the paper does not compare to methods that perform open-world tasks. "Walter J Scheirer, Anderson de Rezende Rocha, Archana Sapkota, and Terrance E Boult. Toward open set recognition. IEEE transactions on pattern analysis and machine intelligence (2012)" "Abhijit Bendale and Terrance Boult. Towards open world recognition. In Proceedings of the IEEE conference on computer vision and pa
Videos
No videos yet. Explain this paper in a talk, walkthrough, or lecture? Add one.
Taxonomy
TopicsAnomaly Detection Techniques and Applications · Adversarial Robustness in Machine Learning · Machine Learning in Materials Science
MethodsFocus
