CoNO: Complex Neural Operator for Continuous Dynamical Systems
Karn Tiwari, N M Anoop Krishnan, Prathosh A P

TL;DR
CoNO introduces a complex neural operator that leverages complex fractional Fourier transforms and algebraic properties to improve modeling of continuous dynamical systems, demonstrating superior performance and robustness across various tasks.
Contribution
The paper proposes a novel complex neural operator using fractional Fourier domain parameterization and complex-valued neural networks, enhancing representation and robustness in modeling PDEs.
Findings
Effective capture of PDEs with a single complex Fourier transform
Outperforms state-of-the-art models in robustness and data efficiency
Demonstrates superior performance in zero-shot super-resolution and out-of-distribution tasks
Abstract
Neural operators extend data-driven models to map between infinite-dimensional functional spaces. These models have successfully solved continuous dynamical systems represented by differential equations, viz weather forecasting, fluid flow, or solid mechanics. However, the existing operators still rely on real space, thereby losing rich representations potentially captured in the complex space by functional transforms. In this paper, we introduce a Complex Neural Operator (CoNO), that parameterizes the integral kernel in the complex fractional Fourier domain. Additionally, the model employing a complex-valued neural network along with aliasing-free activation functions preserves the complex values and complex algebraic properties, thereby enabling improved representation, robustness to noise, and generalization. We show that the model effectively captures the underlying partial…
Peer Reviews
Decision·ICLR 2024 Conference Withdrawn Submission
While there are some notational discrepancies, as pointed out in the section below, I think the authors do a overall good job in sticking to notation and make the method section very clear to understand. The placement of the proposed method within existing work is adequate. I think the use of complex numbers along-side fractional Fourier transform is novel and something that is being demonstrated well. I specifically like section 2.4 where authors describe a simple yet effective anti-aliasing
I think the proposed method is novel, and that it can give comparable performance. What is not clear from the presentation both theoretical justification and/or empirical evidence is the benefits that it can have over FNO. Please see questions section for specific. The writing/overall presentation can be improved. - For example, Table 1, caption is not all descriptive, without first introducing what is order of transform, a comparison is being made. This table is not necessary in my opinion. -
1. The proposed approach is clean and easy to follow. 2. Complex neural operator permits learnable order and a complete usage of complex representation space. 3. The method seems to perform well in zero shot superresolution and is more robust to noise.
1. In general the performance improvement of CoNO over FNO seems marginal on most of the datasets. It is not sufficiently convincing to demonstrate the efficacy of the proposed modules. Similar observations can be found in Table 7 for the ablation studies. 2. Lacking theoretical insights on why the model is more robust and performs better on OOD tasks, compared with, e.g., FNO. 3. Presentation can be further improved. For instance, it would be better to index each paragraph in section 3 with a
- Fractional Fourier Transform is an interesting concept, yet to be introduced into the deep learning community.
- There is no information about baseline models and training/inference times. There is a link to the code repo added, but it is impossible to figure out the settings and hyperparamters of the models. Given that the proposed model performs marginally better than FNO models this makes it impossible to judge. Side remark: Pytorch FFTs on complex inputs are much slower than on real inputs (torch.fft vs torch.rfft), thus runtime comparisons would be needed. - The main formula (Eq 3) is hardly explai
1. **Complex Domain Operations**: The ability of the CONO model to operate within the complex domain enables it to effectively capture the intricacies of complex numerical signals. This not only augments its expressive power but also enhances feature extraction, making it adept at representing and analyzing complex data. 2. **Structure-preserving Architecture**: The CONO aims to maintain complex continuous-discrete equivalence, ensuring that the Shannon-Whittaker-Kotel’nikov theorem is obeyed f
1. The articulation and expression of the manuscript require further refinement. In several sections, the clarity of the narrative falls short, making it challenging for the reader to grasp the content. 2. The operations of CONO within the complex domain allow it to effectively capture and represent the nuances of complex signals. This enhances its expressive power and improves feature extraction. However, due to the intricacies of the involved operations and transformations, a significant amou
Videos
No videos yet. Explain this paper in a talk, walkthrough, or lecture? Add one.
Taxonomy
TopicsImage and Signal Denoising Methods · Model Reduction and Neural Networks
