Hot Jupiters Have Giant Companions: Evidence for Coplanar High-Eccentricity Migration

TL;DR

This study analyzes planetary systems with giant planets, revealing that hot Jupiters are commonly accompanied by massive, eccentric outer giants, supporting coplanar high-eccentricity migration as their formation mechanism.

Contribution

It provides the first population-level evidence linking outer giant companions' properties to hot Jupiter formation, emphasizing coplanar high-eccentricity migration.

Findings

Outer giant companions are ubiquitous in hot Jupiter systems.

Outer companions are more massive than hot Jupiters within the same system.

Outer companions in hot Jupiter systems have higher eccentricities.

Abstract

This study considers the characteristics of planetary systems with giant planets based on a population-level analysis of the California Legacy Survey planet catalog. We identified three characteristics common to hot Jupiters. First, while not all hot Jupiters have a detected outer giant planet companion ($M \sin i$ = 0.3--30 $M_{\textrm{Jup}}$), such companions are ubiquitous when survey completeness corrections are applied for orbital periods out to 40,000 days. Giant harboring systems without a hot Jupiter also host at least one outer giant planet companion per system. Second, the mass distributions of hot Jupiters and other giant planets are indistinguishable. However, within a planetary system that includes a hot Jupiter, the outer giant planet companions are at least $3\times$ more massive than the inner hot Jupiters. Third, the eccentricity distribution of the outer companions in hot Jupiter systems (with an average model eccentricity of $\langle e\rangle=0.34\pm0.05$) is different from the corresponding outer planets in planetary systems without hot Jupiters ($\langle e\rangle=0.19\pm0.02$). We conclude that the existence of two gas giants, where the outermost planet has an eccentricity $\ge0.2$ and is $3\times$ more massive, are key factors in the production of a hot Jupiter. Our simple model based on these factors predicts that $\sim$10\% of warm and cold Jupiter systems will by chance meet these assembly criteria, which is consistent with our measurement of $16\pm6\%$ relative occurrence of hot Jupiter systems to all giant-harboring systems. We find that these three features favor coplanar high-eccentricity migration as the dominant mechanism for hot Jupiter formation.