Simultaneity of consciousness with physical reality: the key that unlocks the mind-matter problem

TL;DR

This paper proposes a new fundamental principle linking consciousness directly to physical reality, suggesting consciousness can create causal freedom independently, with testable predictions differing from Integrated Information Theory.

Contribution

It introduces a deductive approach to the mind-matter problem, proposing that conscious experience can generate causal power without reliance on physical structures like IIT.

Findings

Consciousness can produce causal freedom independently of physical content.

The theory makes testable predictions about brain function that differ from IIT.

It provides a new conceptual bridge between subjective experience and physics.

Abstract

The problem of explaining the relationship between subjective experience and physical reality remains difficult and unresolved. In most explanations, consciousness is epiphenomenal, without causal power. The most notable exception is Integrated Information Theory (IIT), which provides a causal explanation for consciousness. However, IIT relies on an identity between subjectivity and a particular type of physical structure, namely with an information structure that has intrinsic causal power greater than the sum of its parts. Any theory that relies on a psycho-physical identity must eventually appeal to panpsychism, which undermines that theorys claim to be fundamental. IIT has recently pivoted towards a strong version of causal emergence, but macroscopic causal structures cannot be causally stronger than its microscopic parts without some new physical law or governing principle. The approach taken here is designed to uncover such a principle. The decisive argument is entirely deductive from initial premises that are phenomenologically certain. If correct, the arguments prove that conscious experience is sufficient to create additional degrees of causal freedom independently of the content of experience, and in a manner that is unpredictable and unobservable by any temporally sequential means. This provides a fundamental principle about consciousness, and a conceptual bridge between it and the physics describing what is experienced. The principle makes testable predictions about brain function, with notable differences from IIT, some of which are also empirically testable.