Impacts of DEM Type and Resolution on Deep Learning-Based Flood Inundation Mapping

TL;DR

This study evaluates how different types and resolutions of digital elevation models influence the accuracy of deep learning-based flood mapping, demonstrating that coarser DEMs can still be effective for rapid flood prediction in data-scarce regions.

Contribution

It provides a systematic analysis of DEM type and resolution effects on flood prediction accuracy using deep learning, with practical insights for data-scarce regions.

Findings

30 m DTM outperforms 30 m DSM by 21% in accuracy

Increasing DEM resolution from 30 m to 15 m raises RMSE by 50%

Coarser DEMs remain viable for rapid flood prediction

Abstract

The increasing availability of hydrological and physiographic spatiotemporal data has boosted machine learning's role in rapid flood mapping. Yet, data scarcity, especially high-resolution DEMs, challenges regions with limited access. This paper examines how DEM type and resolution affect flood prediction accuracy, utilizing a cutting-edge deep learning (DL) method called 1D convolutional neural network (CNN). It utilizes synthetic hydrographs as training input and water depth data obtained from LISFLOOD-FP, a 2D hydrodynamic model, as target data. This study investigates digital surface models (DSMs) and digital terrain models (DTMs) derived from a 1 m LIDAR-based DTM, with resolutions from 15 to 30 m. The methodology is applied and assessed in an established benchmark, the city of Carlisle, UK. The models' performance is then evaluated and compared against an observed flood event using RMSE, Bias, and Fit indices. Leveraging the insights gained from this region, the paper discusses the applicability of the methodology to address the challenges encountered in a data-scarce flood-prone region, exemplified by Pakistan. Results indicated that utilizing a 30 m DTM outperformed a 30 m DSM in terms of flood depth prediction accuracy by about 21% during the flood peak stage, highlighting the superior performance of DTM at lower resolutions. Increasing the resolution of DTM to 15 m resulted in a minimum 50% increase in RMSE and a 20% increase in fit index across all flood stages. The findings emphasize that while a coarser resolution DEM may impact the accuracy of machine learning models, it remains a viable option for rapid flood prediction. However, even a slight improvement in data resolution in data-scarce regions would provide significant added value, ultimately enhancing flood risk management.