Rank-adaptive covariance testing with applications to genomics and neuroimaging

TL;DR

This paper introduces RACT, a new covariance testing method that effectively detects low-rank structure differences in high-dimensional biomedical data, improving power while maintaining error control.

Contribution

The paper proposes RACT, a novel rank-adaptive covariance test leveraging Ky-Fan(k) norms and permutation inference for enhanced detection of low-rank covariance differences.

Findings

RACT outperforms existing methods in simulations.

It effectively detects covariance differences in genomics and neuroimaging.

Permutation testing ensures exact Type I error control.

Abstract

In biomedical studies, testing for differences in covariance offers scientific insights beyond mean differences, especially when differences are driven by complex joint behavior between features. However, when differences in joint behavior are weakly dispersed across many dimensions and arise from differences in low-rank structures within the data, as is often the case in genomics and neuroimaging, existing two-sample covariance testing methods may suffer from power loss. The Ky-Fan(k) norm, defined by the sum of the top Ky-Fan(k) singular values, is a simple and intuitive matrix norm able to capture signals caused by differences in low-rank structures between matrices, but its statistical properties in hypothesis testing have not been studied well. In this paper, we investigate the behavior of the Ky-Fan(k) norm in two-sample covariance testing. Ultimately, we propose a novel methodology, Rank-Adaptive Covariance Testing (RACT), which is able to leverage differences in low-rank structures found in the covariance matrices of two groups in order to maximize power. RACT uses permutation for statistical inference, ensuring an exact Type I error control. We validate RACT in simulation studies and evaluate its performance when testing for differences in gene expression networks between two types of lung cancer, as well as testing for covariance heterogeneity in diffusion tensor imaging (DTI) data taken on two different scanner types.