Using quantitative magneto-optical imaging to reveal why the ac susceptibility of superconducting films is history-independent

TL;DR

This study uses quantitative magneto-optical imaging to explain why the ac susceptibility of superconducting films remains consistent regardless of magnetic or thermal history, even amidst flux avalanches.

Contribution

The paper demonstrates that ac magneto-optical imaging can reliably analyze local flux dynamics and frequency-independent ac susceptibility in superconducting films, revealing flux behavior details.

Findings

Reversible ac susceptibility observed despite flux avalanches

Flux avalanches mainly affect flux distribution during the first ac cycle

Presence of a vortex-antivortex annihilation zone near flux front

Abstract

Measurements of the temperature-dependent ac magnetic susceptibility of superconducting films reveal reversible responses, i.e., irrespective of the magnetic and thermal history of the sample. This experimental fact is observed even in the presence of stochastic and certainly irreversible magnetic flux avalanches which, in principle, should randomly affect the results. In this work, we explain such an apparent contradiction by exploring the spatial resolution of magneto-optical imaging. To achieve this, we successfully compare standard frequency-independent first harmonic ac magnetic susceptibility results for a superconducting thin film with those obtained by ac-emulating magneto-optical imaging (acMOI). A quantitative analysis also provides information regarding flux avalanches, reveals the presence of a vortex-antivortex annihilation zone in the region in which a smooth flux front interacts with pre-established avalanches, and demonstrates that the major impact on the flux distribution within the superconductor happens during the first ac cycle. Our results establish acMOI as a reliable approach for studying frequency-independent ac field effects in superconducting thin films while capturing local aspects of flux dynamics, otherwise inaccessible via global magnetometry techniques.