Asymmetric Capture into Neptunian 1:2 Resonance

TL;DR

This study uses toy models to systematically analyze how planetesimals are captured into asymmetric 1:2 resonance with Neptune, revealing dynamics that influence population ratios and potential clues to Solar system evolution.

Contribution

The paper introduces a systematic approach using toy models to study asymmetric resonance capture, highlighting the effects of migration slowdown and eccentricity on population ratios.

Findings

Migration slowdown affects population ratio between islands.

Eccentricity may preserve information about Solar system evolution.

Asymmetric capture dynamics can be tuned independently of migration history.

Abstract

The asymmetric resonance configuration characterized by the critical angle librating around centres other than 0 or 180 degree, is found in the 1:N mean motion resonance. The asymmetric 1:2 resonance with Neptune is of particular interest because the two asymmetric islands seem to host different populations, and this might be a direct clue to understanding the early evolution of the Solar system. The asymmetry has been investigated from both observational and theoretical perspectives, but conclusions among studies vary widely. In this paper using toy models, we carefully designed a series of tests to systematically study the capture of planetesimals into the leading and trailing resonance islands. Although these tests may not reproduce exactly the real processes the Solar system experienced, they reveal some typical dynamics in the resonance capture. Since the real Twotinos have small to moderate inclinations, as the first attempt, we adopted in this paper planar models to investigate the mechanisms that may lead to asymmetric capture by the leading and trailing islands, including their size variation during the outward migration of Neptune, the stickiness of the leading island, and the migration slowdown effect. Particularly, we find that the ratio between the populations of the leading and trailing islands can be easily tuned by introducing the slowdown effect in the migration model, thus may be not a good tracer of the migration history. However, the eccentricity of objects trapped in two asymmetric islands may conserve some valuable information of the early evolution of the Solar system.