Mixed mode transition in boundary layers: Helical instability

TL;DR

This study investigates a mixed mode transition in boundary layers, revealing a helical instability mode through stability analysis, which explains the helical patterns observed in transitional flows.

Contribution

It identifies a new helical instability mode in boundary layer transition, distinct from known modes, using stability analysis of DNS-derived base flows.

Findings

Helical instability mode appears earlier than visualized structures.

Helical patterns are linked to a specific streak configuration.

Mixed mode transition involves unique instability mechanisms.

Abstract

Recent (Bose \& Durbin, \textit{Phys. Rev. Fluids}, 1, 073602, 2016) direct numerical simulations (DNS) of adverse- and zero-pressure-gradient boundary layers beneath moderate levels of free stream turbulence ($Tu$ $\le 2\%$) revealed a \textit{mixed mode} transition regime, intermediate between orderly and bypass routes. In this regime, the amplitudes of the Klebanoff streaks and instability waves are similar, and potentially can interact. Three-dimensional visualizations of transitional eddies revealed a helical pattern, quite distinct from the sinuous and varicose forms seen in pure bypass transition. This raises the fundamental question of whether the helical pattern could be attributed to a previously unknown instability mode. Two-dimensional stability analyses are performed herein for base flows extracted from DNS flow fields. The three-dimensional structure of the eigenfunction of the most unstable mode indeed reveals a helical pattern. These instability modes are obtained significantly earlier than helical structures are seen in flow visualizations, even for innocuous base flow structures. It is inferred that the instability mode is the underlying cause of helical patterns that emerge in the transition region. The streak configuration leading to the formation of the helical mode instability is different from those leading to sinuous and varicose modes in previous studies of pure bypass transition. Thus, the mixed mode precursor is the distinctive cause.