General validity of the exponential law for the effect of concentration polarization in reverse osmosis in a stirred-cell geometry, including an activity correction for 1:1 salt solutions

TL;DR

This study confirms the exponential law's validity for concentration polarization in reverse osmosis and enhances the model by incorporating activity corrections for salt solutions, improving accuracy in predicting salt concentration effects.

Contribution

The paper demonstrates that the exponential law applies to a more realistic stirred-cell model and introduces activity corrections based on Bjerrum theory to improve concentration polarization predictions.

Findings

Exponential law holds in a stirred-cell geometry without a stagnant film.

Including activity coefficients increases salt concentration at the membrane.

Activity correction can be approximated by reducing the mass transfer coefficient.

Abstract

Reverse osmosis (RO) is a method to desalinate water with membranes and an applied pressure. Very important in the theory of mass transport in RO is the concentration polarization (CP) layer, which develops on the upstream side of the membrane because of a combination of salt convection and diffusion. Because of the CP-effect, the salt concentration at the membrane surface is higher than in the channel, and this increases the osmotic pressure there, and thus transmembrane water flux is reduced (the osmotic pressure acts against water flux), while salt leakage through the membrane increases. So it is very important to understand and describe the CP-layer accurately. We analyze a one-dimensional geometry, which is of relevance for a typical lab-scale RO setup using small membrane coupons where the solution on the feed side of the membrane is stirred. For this geometry, the standard film layer approach is often used that assumes a stagnant film layer of a defined thickness, which however does not exist in reality. We set up a model without that assumption but including refreshment of solution because of the flow of water along the membrane due to stirring. We show that the `exponential law' for the CP-layer that is predicted by the the film model, also applies for this more accurate model. We further improve the model by including the activity coefficient of salt ions, as described by the Bjerrum theory that is based on ion-ion Coulombic interactions. We evaluate the original linearized Bjerrum theory as well as an extended Bjerrum equation that is valid up to 1.5 M salt concentration. We show how including this activity correction leads to a reduction of the diffusional driving force at high concentration, and thus the salt concentration at the membrane further increases. However, the effect can be easily included by reducing the CP-layer mass transfer coefficient by a fixed percentage.