Towards Few-shot Coordination: Revisiting Ad-hoc Teamplay Challenge In the Game of Hanabi

TL;DR

This paper evaluates the adaptability of zero-shot coordination algorithms in multi-agent reinforcement learning within the Hanabi game, revealing that naive methods can match state-of-the-art algorithms in adaptation speed and highlighting the importance of training hyper-parameters.

Contribution

It introduces a new framework and metric for assessing agent adaptability in Hanabi, and provides empirical insights into how hyper-parameters influence adaptability of MARL algorithms.

Findings

Naive IQL agents adapt as quickly as SOTA OBL in most cases.

Hyper-parameters controlling data diversity and optimization significantly affect adaptability.

Current ZSC algorithms require extensive interaction samples to adapt to new partners.

Abstract

Cooperative Multi-agent Reinforcement Learning (MARL) algorithms with Zero-Shot Coordination (ZSC) have gained significant attention in recent years. ZSC refers to the ability of agents to coordinate zero-shot (without additional interaction experience) with independently trained agents. While ZSC is crucial for cooperative MARL agents, it might not be possible for complex tasks and changing environments. Agents also need to adapt and improve their performance with minimal interaction with other agents. In this work, we show empirically that state-of-the-art ZSC algorithms have poor performance when paired with agents trained with different learning methods, and they require millions of interaction samples to adapt to these new partners. To investigate this issue, we formally defined a framework based on a popular cooperative multi-agent game called Hanabi to evaluate the adaptability of MARL methods. In particular, we created a diverse set of pre-trained agents and defined a new metric called adaptation regret that measures the agent's ability to efficiently adapt and improve its coordination performance when paired with some held-out pool of partners on top of its ZSC performance. After evaluating several SOTA algorithms using our framework, our experiments reveal that naive Independent Q-Learning (IQL) agents in most cases adapt as quickly as the SOTA ZSC algorithm Off-Belief Learning (OBL). This finding raises an interesting research question: How to design MARL algorithms with high ZSC performance and capability of fast adaptation to unseen partners. As a first step, we studied the role of different hyper-parameters and design choices on the adaptability of current MARL algorithms. Our experiments show that two categories of hyper-parameters controlling the training data diversity and optimization process have a significant impact on the adaptability of Hanabi agents.