Evaluating SZZ Implementations: An Empirical Study on the Linux Kernel

TL;DR

This study evaluates the effectiveness of six SZZ algorithms on a large, developer-reviewed dataset from the Linux kernel, revealing significant recall decline, the prevalence of ghost commits, and proposing an improved tracing method called TC-SZZ.

Contribution

The paper provides the first large-scale evaluation of SZZ algorithms on Linux kernel data and introduces TC-SZZ, a new method that improves bug-inducing commit identification.

Findings

SZZ algorithms' recall declined by 13.8% on Linux data.

17.47% of bug-fixing commits are ghost commits.

TC-SZZ identified 17.7% of failure cases excluding ghosts.

Abstract

The SZZ algorithm is used to connect bug-fixing commits to the earlier commits that introduced bugs. This algorithm has many applications and many variants have been devised. However, there are some types of commits that cannot be traced by the SZZ algorithm, referred to as "ghost commits". The evaluation of how these ghost commits impact the SZZ algorithm remains limited. Moreover, these algorithms have been evaluated on datasets created by software engineering researchers from information in bug trackers and version controlled histories. Since Oct 2013, the Linux kernel developers have started labelling bug-fixing patches with the commit identifiers of the corresponding bug-inducing commit(s) as a standard practice. As of v6.1-rc5, 76,046 pairs of bug-fixing patches and bug-inducing commits are available. This provides a unique opportunity to evaluate the SZZ algorithm on a large dataset that has been created and reviewed by project developers, entirely independently of the biases of software engineering researchers. In this paper, we apply six SZZ algorithms to 76,046 pairs of bug-fixing patches and bug-introducing commits from the Linux kernel. Our findings reveal that SZZ algorithms experience a more significant decline in recall on our dataset (13.8%) as compared to prior findings reported by Rosa et al., and the disparities between the individual SZZ algorithms diminish. Moreover, we find that 17.47% of bug-fixing commits are ghost commits. Finally, we propose Tracing-Commit SZZ (TC-SZZ), that traces all commits in the change history of lines modified or deleted in bug-fixing commits. Applying TC-SZZ to all failure cases, excluding ghost commits, we found that TC-SZZ could identify 17.7% of them. Our further analysis found that 34.6% of bug-inducing commits were in the function history, 27.5% in the file history (but not in the function history), and...