Getting from Generative AI to Trustworthy AI: What LLMs might learn from Cyc

TL;DR

This paper discusses the limitations of current generative AI, proposes a hybrid approach combining large language models with symbolic reasoning like Cyc, to achieve trustworthy, interpretable, and logically sound AI systems.

Contribution

It introduces a framework for integrating LLMs with symbolic reasoning systems like Cyc to enhance trustworthiness and interpretability of AI.

Findings

Cyc can reason in higher order logic in real time.

Hybrid AI approaches can improve trustworthiness and interpretability.

Explicit knowledge and rules enable step-by-step reasoning with provenance.

Abstract

Generative AI, the most popular current approach to AI, consists of large language models (LLMs) that are trained to produce outputs that are plausible, but not necessarily correct. Although their abilities are often uncanny, they are lacking in aspects of reasoning, leading LLMs to be less than completely trustworthy. Furthermore, their results tend to be both unpredictable and uninterpretable. We lay out 16 desiderata for future AI, and discuss an alternative approach to AI which could theoretically address many of the limitations associated with current approaches: AI educated with curated pieces of explicit knowledge and rules of thumb, enabling an inference engine to automatically deduce the logical entailments of all that knowledge. Even long arguments produced this way can be both trustworthy and interpretable, since the full step-by-step line of reasoning is always available, and for each step the provenance of the knowledge used can be documented and audited. There is however a catch: if the logical language is expressive enough to fully represent the meaning of anything we can say in English, then the inference engine runs much too slowly. That's why symbolic AI systems typically settle for some fast but much less expressive logic, such as knowledge graphs. We describe how one AI system, Cyc, has developed ways to overcome that tradeoff and is able to reason in higher order logic in real time. We suggest that any trustworthy general AI will need to hybridize the approaches, the LLM approach and more formal approach, and lay out a path to realizing that dream.