Highly-mass-loaded hot galactic winds are unstable to cool filament formation

TL;DR

This study investigates the stability of hot galactic winds with mass-loading, revealing that high mass-loading induces thermal instability and filament formation, which may explain observed cool filaments in starburst superwinds.

Contribution

It provides a combined perturbation and 3D simulation analysis showing conditions under which mass-loaded hot winds become thermally unstable and form filaments, extending previous steady-state models.

Findings

Mass-loading stabilizes flows over a broad parameter range.

High mass-loading causes thermal instability and filament formation.

Filament kinematics depend on the mass-loading profile slope.

Abstract

When cool clouds are ram-pressure accelerated by a hot supersonic galactic wind, some of the clouds may be shredded by hydrodynamical instabilities and incorporated into the hot flow. Recent one-dimensional steady-state calculations show how cool cloud entrainment directly affects the bulk thermodynamics, kinematics, and observational characteristics of the hot gas. In particular, mass-loading decelerates the hot flow and changes its entropy. Here, we investigate the stability of planar and spherical mass-loaded hot supersonic flows using both perturbation analysis and three-dimensional time-dependent radiative hydrodynamical simulations. We show that mass-loading is stable over a broad range of parameters and that the 1D time-steady analytic solutions exactly reproduce the 3D time-dependent calculations, provided that the flow does not decelerate sufficiently to become subsonic. For higher values of the mass-loading, the flow develops a sonic point and becomes thermally unstable, rapidly cooling and forming elongated dense cometary filaments. We explore the mass-loading parameters required to reach a sonic point and the radiative formation of these filaments. For certain approximations, we can derive simple analytic criteria. In general a mass-loading rate similar to the initial mass outflow rate is required. In this sense, the destruction of small cool clouds by a hot flow may ultimately spontaneously generate fast cool filaments, as observed in starburst superwinds. Lastly, we find that the kinematics of filaments is sensitive to the slope of the mass-loading function. Filaments move faster than the surrounding wind if mass-loading is over long distances whereas filaments move slower than their surroundings if mass-loading is abrupt.