Towards a geometry for syntax

TL;DR

This paper explores a geometric approach to understanding the properties of free models in type theory, focusing on injectivity laws crucial for proof assistants, inspired by Grothendieck's ideas.

Contribution

It introduces a novel geometric framework to prove injectivity laws in free models of Martin-Löf type theory, integrating modern methods with classical ideas.

Findings

Established a geometric proof of injectivity in free models

Connected type-theoretic properties with Grothendieck's foundational concepts

Enhanced understanding of free model properties for proof assistant implementation

Abstract

It often happens that free algebras for a given theory satisfy useful reasoning principles that are not preserved under homomorphisms of algebras, and hence need not hold in an arbitrary algebra. For instance, if $M$ is the free monoid on a set $A$, then the scalar multiplication function $A\times M \to M$ is injective. Therefore, when reasoning in the formal theory of monoids under $A$, it is possible to use this injectivity law to make sound deductions even about monoids under $A$ for which scalar multiplication is not injective -- a principle known in algebra as the permanence of identity. Properties of this kind are of fundamental practical importance to the logicians and computer scientists who design and implement computerized proof assistants like Lean and Coq, as they enable the formal reductions of equational problems that make type checking tractable. As type theories have become increasingly more sophisticated, it has become more and more difficult to establish the useful properties of their free models that enable effective implementation. These obstructions have facilitated a fruitful return to foundational work in type theory, which has taken on a more geometrical flavor than ever before. Here we expose a modern way to prove a highly non-trivial injectivity law for free models of Martin-L\"of type theory, paying special attention to the ways that contemporary methods in type theory have been influenced by three important ideas of the Grothendieck school: the relative point of view, the language of universes, and the recollement of generalized spaces.