Exploring acceptance of autonomous vehicle policies using KeyBERT and SNA: Targeting engineering students

TL;DR

This study compares two text-mining methods to analyze engineering students' acceptance of autonomous vehicle policies, revealing insights into user perceptions and potential risks associated with AV deployment.

Contribution

It introduces a novel comparison of CNA and C-SNA methods for understanding user acceptance of AV policies using student comments.

Findings

C-SNA provides clearer insights with fewer nodes.

Students identified potential risks in AV policies.

Text mining reveals user perceptions and concerns.

Abstract

This study aims to explore user acceptance of Autonomous Vehicle (AV) policies with improved text-mining methods. Recently, South Korean policymakers have viewed Autonomous Driving Car (ADC) and Autonomous Driving Robot (ADR) as next-generation means of transportation that will reduce the cost of transporting passengers and goods. They support the construction of V2I and V2V communication infrastructures for ADC and recognize that ADR is equivalent to pedestrians to promote its deployment into sidewalks. To fill the gap where end-user acceptance of these policies is not well considered, this study applied two text-mining methods to the comments of graduate students in the fields of Industrial, Mechanical, and Electronics-Electrical-Computer. One is the Co-occurrence Network Analysis (CNA) based on TF-IWF and Dice coefficient, and the other is the Contextual Semantic Network Analysis (C-SNA) based on both KeyBERT, which extracts keywords that contextually represent the comments, and double cosine similarity. The reason for comparing these approaches is to balance interest not only in the implications for the AV policies but also in the need to apply quality text mining to this research domain. Significantly, the limitation of frequency-based text mining, which does not reflect textual context, and the trade-off of adjusting thresholds in Semantic Network Analysis (SNA) were considered. As the results of comparing the two approaches, the C-SNA provided the information necessary to understand users' voices using fewer nodes and features than the CNA. The users who pre-emptively understood the AV policies based on their engineering literacy and the given texts revealed potential risks of the AV accident policies. This study adds suggestions to manage these risks to support the successful deployment of AVs on public roads.