Widest scales in turbulent channels

TL;DR

This study investigates the influence of domain size on the widest spanwise scales in turbulent channel flows at Re_tau=550, finding that most energetic fluctuations are unaffected by domain width, confirming the robustness of large-scale structures.

Contribution

The paper provides evidence that the widest spanwise scales in turbulent channels are not artifacts of domain size, supporting the validity of simulations with limited spanwise extent.

Findings

90% of energy contained in smaller scales is unaffected by domain size.

Widest scales are not artifacts of domain truncation.

Spanwise coherent structures persist across different domain sizes.

Abstract

The widest spanwise scales in turbulent channel flows are studied through the use of three periodic channel-flow simulations at friction Reynolds number $\mathrm{Re}_{\tau}=550$. The length and height of the channels are the same in all cases ($L_x/h=8\pi$ and $L_y/h=2$ respectively), while the width is progressively doubled: $L_z/h = \{4\pi, 8\pi, 16\pi\}$. The effects of increasing the domain can not be determined with statistical significance in our simulations, since the difference in the statistics between the simulations is of the same order as the errors of convergence. A channel flow similar to the smaller one ($\textit{J. Fluid Mech.}$, vol. 500, 2004, pp. 135--144), which was averaged over a very long time, was used as a reference. The one-dimensional spanwise spectrum of the streamwise velocity is computed with the aim of assessing the domain-size effect on the widest scales. Our results indicate that $90\%$ of the total streamwise energetic fluctuations is recovered without a significant influence of the size of the domain. The remaining $10\%$ of the energy reflects that the widest scales in the outer layer are the ones most significantly affected by the spanwise length of the domain. The power-spectral density for $k_z = 0$ remains constant even if the size of the domain in the spanwise direction is increased up to 4 times the standard spanwise length, indicating that wide, spanwise coherent structures are not an artifact of domain truncation.