Doubly ranked tests of location for grouped functional data

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel doubly ranked nonparametric testing method for grouped functional data, improving power and maintaining error control, with applications across various scientific fields.

Contribution

The paper develops a new doubly ranked test approach for functional data that incorporates the null hypothesis, enhancing power over existing methods.

Findings

Doubly ranked tests outperform traditional methods in power.

The proposed tests maintain proper type I error rates.

Extensions to multiple samples show good test characteristics.

Abstract

Nonparametric tests for functional data are a challenging class of tests to work with because of the potentially high dimensional nature of the data. One of the main challenges for considering rank-based tests, like the Mann-Whitney or Wilcoxon Rank Sum tests (MWW), is that the unit of observation is typically a curve. Thus any rank-based test must consider ways of ranking curves. While several procedures, including depth-based methods, have recently been used to create scores for rank-based tests, these scores are not constructed under the null and often introduce additional, uncontrolled for variability. We therefore reconsider the problem of rank-based tests for functional data and develop an alternative approach that incorporates the null hypothesis throughout. Our approach first ranks realizations from the curves at each measurement occurrence, then calculates a summary statistic for the ranks of each subject, and finally re-ranks the summary statistic in a procedure we refer to as a doubly ranked test. We propose two summaries for the middle step: a sufficient statistic and the average rank. As we demonstrate, doubly rank tests are more powerful while maintaining ideal type I error in the two sample, MWW setting. We also extend our framework to more than two samples, developing a Kruskal-Wallis test for functional data which exhibits good test characteristics as well. Finally, we illustrate the use of doubly ranked tests in functional data contexts from material science, climatology, and public health policy.