The Celestial Vault is Not a Dome: Implications for the Moon Illusion

TL;DR

This study challenges the traditional dome model of the celestial vault by using landmark-based pointing experiments, revealing that the vault does not intersect the ground and suggesting new insights into the moon illusion.

Contribution

It introduces a novel method for mapping the celestial vault and provides evidence against the standard dome model, impacting theories of the moon illusion.

Findings

The celestial vault does not intersect the ground.

The vault leaves a 20-degree indeterminate space above the horizon.

Results contradict the Size-Distance Invariance Hypothesis.

Abstract

The moon illusion, in which the moon appears larger at the horizon than at higher altitudes, has been investigated since antiquity, yet it remains not fully explained. Our method of investigating the phenomenon is based on that attributed to Martin Folkes. Folkes suggests investigators identify landmarks on the ground and request human subjects indicate a place in the sky that they perceive to be above that location by raising their arm and pointing. The intersection of a vertical line rising out of the landmark and the ray extending from the subject's finger then identifies a point on the subject's model of the celestial vault. When repeated for landmarks covering a range of distances, the subject's entire celestial vault can be traced. We asked 30 subjects to perform such an identification on a series of points between a horizontal distance of 3 and 12600 meters across featureless open water in Verplanck and Ithaca, New York. The resulting data are in disagreement with the widely presumed flattened dome model, and, in particular, the Size-Distance Invariance Hypothesis. In addition, we find that the vault does not intersect the ground and leaves an indeterminate space of about 20 degrees altitude above the horizon with no correspondence to the ground. It is in this region that the Moon Illusion is most pronounced.